2024 Indy Eleven season

Indy Eleven
2024 season
Owner	List Brian Bauer; Don Gottwald; Shane Hageman; Jeffrey Laborsky; Fred Merritt; Ersal Ozdemir; Quinn Ricker; Chris Traylor;
Head coach	Sean McAuley
Stadium	Carroll Stadium
USL Championship	Eastern Conference: 4th
USL Playoffs	Conference quarterfinals
2024 U.S. Open Cup	Semi-finals
Top goalscorer	League: Blake, A. Williams (10); All: A. Williams (13)
Highest home attendance	10,780 ; (October 5 vs. Louisville)
Lowest home attendance	7,623; (November 3 vs. Rhode Island)
Average home league attendance	9,795
Biggest win	4–0 ; (September 28 vs Miami)
Biggest defeat	0–5; (August 2 at Charleston)
Home colors	Away colors
	← 2023 2025 →

The 2024 Indy Eleven season was the most recent season for Indy Eleven, a professional soccer club based in Indianapolis, Indiana, beginning in February 2024 and ending in November 2024, comprising 40 competitive matches and 6 friendlies. It was also the club's eleventh season of existence, their eleventh consecutive season in the second tier of American soccer, and their seventh season in the USL Championship. The team also participated in the U.S. Open Cup, making the semi-finals for the first time in the club's history.

Background

The previous season was the second consecutive season where the USL played a 34-match schedule divided into two conferences with both conferences having a single table. While being the first where all sides from both conferences played against each other.^[2]

The 2023 season was seen as relatively successful for Indy, as they qualified for the USL Championship Playoffs for the first time since 2019 by finishing 6th in the Eastern Conference.^[3] The team lost to eventual finalists Charleston Battery in the Conference Quarterfinals on October 22, 2023.^[4] The team exited the U.S. Open Cup in the third round with a 1–0 away loss to MLS side Columbus Crew on April 26, 2023.^[5]

Following the conclusion of the 2023 season the club parted ways with head coach Mark Lowry, who later became the head coach for MLS Next Pro side Real Monarchs.^[6] The team announced the arrival of former Manchester United player and Minnesota United interim head coach Sean McAuley as their new head coach on January 8, 2024.^[7]

Roster

As of October 26, 2024^[8]

No.	Name	Position(s)	Date of birth (age)	Signed in	Previous club	League Apps.	League Goals
Goalkeepers
0	Hunter Sulte	GK	April 25, 2002 (age 21)	2024	Portland Timbers (on loan)	26	0
1	Yannik Oettl	GK	(1996-11-19) November 19, 1996 (age 27)	2023	Hartford Athletic	26	0
24	Hayden Vostal	GK	(2005-10-18) October 18, 2005 (age 19)	2024	Indy Eleven Academy	0	0
46	Cayden Crawford	GK	(2006-09-29) September 29, 2006 (age 18)	2024	Indy Eleven Academy	0	0
Defenders
2	Josh O'Brien	DF	(2003-02-07) February 7, 2003 (age 21)	2024	Hamilton Academical	25	1
3	Aedan Stanley	DF	(1999-12-13) December 13, 1999 (age 24)	2024	Miami FC	32	0
5	Callum Chapman-Page	DF	(1995-11-06) November 6, 1995 (age 29)	2023	Miami FC	25	1
15	Adrián Diz Pe	DF	(1994-03-04) March 4, 1994 (age 30)	2023	FC Tulsa	55	4
30	Ben Ofeimu	DF	(2000-09-30) September 30, 2000 (age 24)	2024	Miami FC	30	1
33	Hayden White	DF	(1995-04-15) April 15, 1995 (age 29)	2024	Ebbsfleet United	6	0
37	Logan Neidlinger	DF	(2005-09-06) September 6, 2005 (age 19)	2024	Indy Eleven Adacemy	14	1
41	James Musa	DF	(1992-04-01) April 1, 1992 (age 32)	2024	Colorado Springs Switchbacks	7	1
44	Macauley King	DF	(1995-10-04) October 4, 1995 (age 29)	2023	Colorado Springs Switchbacks	13	0
55	Maverick McCoy	DF	(2007-07-24) July 24, 2007 (age 17)	2024	Indy Eleven Adacemy	0	0
Midfielders
6	Cameron Lindley	MF	(1997-07-18) July 18, 1997 (age 27)	2013	Colorado Springs Switchbacks	62	1
8	Jack Blake	MF	(1994-09-22) September 22, 1994 (age 30)	2023	San Diego Loyal	56	13
12	Diego Sanchez	MF	(2004-12-12) December 12, 2004 (age 19)	2023	Indiana Fire Academy	3	0
14	Aodhan Quinn	MF	(1992-03-22) March 22, 1992 (age 32)	2023	Phoenix Rising	39	9
16	Laurence Wootton	MF	(2000-01-10) January 10, 2000 (age 24)	2024	Chicago Fire (on loan)	24	2
20	Ben Mines	MF	(2000-05-13) May 13, 2000 (age 24)	2024	Miami FC	20	0
22	Tyler Gibson	MF	(1991-01-12) January 12, 1991 (age 33)	2024	Louisville City	21	1
32	Brem Soumaoro	MF	(1996-08-08) August 8, 1996 (age 28)	2024	York United FC	8	0
39	Nikola Ivetic	MF	(2007-06-29) June 29, 2007 (age 17)	2024	Indy Eleven Academy	0	0
Forwards
7	Karsen Henderlong	FW	(2000-09-24) September 24, 2000 (age 24)	2024	Indiana University	5	0
9	Augustine Williams	FW	(1997-08-03) August 3, 1997 (age 27)	2024	Charleston Battery	31	10
10	Romario Williams	FW	(1994-08-15) August 15, 1994 (age 30)	2024	Hartford Athletic	18	2
13	Sebastián Guenzatti	FW	(1991-07-08) July 8, 1991 (age 33)	2023	Tampa Bay Rowdies	61	16
18	Elliot Collier	FW	(1995-02-22) February 22, 1995 (age 29)	2024	San Diego Loyal	30	5
42	Douglas Martínez	FW	(1997-06-05) June 5, 1997 (age 27)	2023	Sacramento Republic	59	7
99	Maalique Foster	FW	(1996-11-05) November 5, 1996 (age 28)	2024	Colorado Springs Switchbacks	11	1

Non-competitive

Preseason

The Eleven released their preseason schedule on January 19, 2024. Six games were announced, four home games and two away games. The Eleven faced clubs in the USL Championship, MLS Next Pro, USL League One, and one collegiate team.^[9]

The Eleven concluded their preseason games following a 3–1 victory over Detroit City on February 29. They ended their preseason series undefeated with five wins and one draw, and a +16 goal differential.^[10]

February 6 Friendly	Pittsburgh Riverhounds	0–0	Indy Eleven	Pittsburgh, PA
12:00 PM EST		Report		Stadium: Highmark Stadium

February 10 Friendly	Indy Eleven	2–0	Chicago Fire FC II	Westfield, IN
6:30 PM EST	Williams 28' Blake 31'	Report		Stadium: Grand Park

February 13 Friendly	Indy Eleven	5–0	Indiana Wesleyan University	Westfield, IN
2:00 PM EST	Blake 12', 31' Henderlong 17' Molina 50' Williams 65'	Report		Stadium: Grand Park

February 18 Friendly	Indy Eleven	7–1	Columbus Crew 2	Westfield, IN
3:00 PM EST	Blake 10', 38', 39' Guenzatti 18' Martinez 33', 33' Williams pen' (75)	Report	Unknown 24'	Stadium: Grand Park

February 24 Friendly	Lexington SC	0–1	Indy Eleven	Lexington, KY
		Report	Unknown unknown'

February 29 Friendly	Indy Eleven	3–1	Detroit City	Westfield, IN
3:00 PM EST	Williams 2' Chapman-Page 29' Stanley 39'	Report	Unknown pen' (17)	Stadium: Grand Park

Competitive

USL Championship

Standings

Pos	Team v t e	Pld	W	L	T	GF	GA	GD	Pts	Qualification
1	Louisville City FC (S)	34	24	6	4	86	43	+43	76	Playoffs
2	Charleston Battery	34	18	6	10	68	35	+33	64
3	Detroit City FC	34	15	8	11	46	32	+14	56
4	Indy Eleven	34	14	11	9	49	50	−1	51
5	Rhode Island FC	34	12	7	15	56	41	+15	51
6	Tampa Bay Rowdies	34	14	12	8	55	46	+9	50
7	Pittsburgh Riverhounds SC	34	12	10	12	41	28	+13	48
8	North Carolina FC	34	13	12	9	54	43	+11	48
9	Birmingham Legion FC	34	13	15	6	44	51	−7	45
10	Hartford Athletic	34	12	14	8	39	52	−13	44
11	Loudoun United FC	34	11	14	9	44	39	+5	42
12	Miami FC	34	3	29	2	26	89	−63	11

Source: USL Championship Standings
Rules for classification: 1) head-to-head points; 2) head-to-head goal differential; 3) points-per game within conference; 4) total wins; 5) total goal differential; 6) total goals scored; 7) points earned against top four Conference finishers; 8) disciplinary points; 9) coin toss or drawing of lots
(S) Players' Shield winner

Match results

The league announced the 34 week regular season campaign for every club on December 18, 2023. Indy began their season away to Western Conference side Oakland Roots on March 9, with their home opener taking place in week three against Sacramento Republic on March 23. The regular season concluded with an away game against Tampa Bay Rowdies on October 26.

The season consists of 34 matches, with the Eleven playing home and away against each Eastern Conference opponent. Indy faced expansion club Rhode Island FC for the first time ever on July 5, drawing 3–3, and also played against North Carolina FC for the first time since 2020 on April 27, winning 2–1.^[11] The top 8 teams in the Eastern Conference will qualify for the 2024 USL Championship playoffs. The Eleven qualified for the playoffs following a 3–2 home win over Birmingham Legion FC on October 19.^[12] This marks the first playoff game hosted by Indy Eleven since 2019.

March 9 1	Oakland Roots	2–1	Indy Eleven	Hayward, CA
10:00 PM EST	Cedeno 3' Tamacas 50' Njiel 89' Donasiyano 98'	Report	Blake 24', 43' Guenzatti 24' Henderlong 25' Chapman-Page 41' Collier 70' Lindley 98'	Stadium: Pioneer Stadium Attendance: 5,146 Referee: Elton Garcia

March 16 2	Memphis 901 FC	1–2	Indy Eleven	Memphis, TN
4:00 PM EDT	Jiminez 15' 45' Yacoubou 25' Cissoko 91' Deric 94' Ward 97' 97'	Report	Chapman-Page 8' Blake 26' Barbir 35' Martínez 42', 57' O'Brien 93'	Stadium: Autozone Park Attendance: 2,621 Referee: Sergii Demianchuk

March 23 3	Indy Eleven	1–1	Sacramento Republic	Indianapolis, IN
7:00 PM EDT	Williams 34' Diz Pe 71' Schneider 79'	Report	Chapman-Page 31' (o.g.) Timmer 83'	Stadium: Carroll Stadium Attendance: 8,451 Referee: Joshua Encarnación

March 30 4	Indy Eleven	1–2	Detroit City	Indianapolis, IN
7:00 PM EDT	Boudadi 15' Guenzatti 24' Diz Pe 87'	Report	Diop 42' Coote 55' Rodriguez 88' Carroll 90'	Stadium: Carroll Stadium Attendance: 9,044 Referee: Velimir Stefanovic

April 6 5	Louisville City	5–3	Indy Eleven	Louisville, KY
4:00 PM EDT	Harris 16', 62', 71' Wilson 41' Wynder 50' Las 77' Serrano 87' Gonzalez Asensi 96'	Report	Martinez 32' Blake 34', 59' Boudadi 40' Oettl 71' McCabe 82' (o.g.)	Stadium: Lynn Family Stadium Attendance: 11,330 Referee: Jeremy Scheer

April 13 6	Indy Eleven	2–4	Charleston Battery	Indianapolis, IN
7:00 PM EDT	Ikoba 27' Guenzatti 28' Chapman-Page 45+2' Blake 52' Stanley 68' King 90+1'	Report	Ycaza 19' Allan 31' Markanich 45+2' King 75' (o.g.) Smith 78' Myers 86'	Stadium: Carroll Stadium Attendance: 8,556 Referee: Greg Dopka

April 20 7	Colorado Springs Switchbacks	1–1	Indy Eleven	Colorado Springs, CO
8:00 PM EDT	Damus 3' Rocha 15' Tejada 20' Rocha 15' Hanya 45' Ackwei 58' Foster 70'	Report	Chapman-Page 14' Lindley 14' Martínez 18' Williams 31' Ofeimu 87'	Stadium: Weidner Field Attendance: 6,687 Referee: Trevor Wiseman

April 27 8	Indy Eleven	2–1	North Carolina FC	Indianapolis, IN
7:00 PM EDT	Ikoba 45+1' Maldonado 48' (o.g.) Martínez 75'	Report	Perez 51' Placias 72' Armstrong 74' Brewer 85' da Costa 90+1'	Stadium: Carroll Stadium Attendance: 10,071 Referee: Eric Tattersall

May 4 9	Monterey Bay	0–1	Indy Eleven	Seaside, CA
10:00 PM EDT	Archimède 75' Fehr 87'	Report	Stanley 71' Diz Pe 74' Collier 88' Blake 90+2'	Stadium: Cardinale Stadium Attendance: 4,504 Referee: Corbyn May

May 12 10	Miami FC	1–3	Indy Eleven	Miami, FL
7:00 PM EDT	Cardona 19' López 31' Mitrano 45+1' Luis Pedro 57'	Report	Gibson 3' Diz Pe 41' Lindley 61' Williams pen' (67), 70' Williams 90+2'	Stadium: FIU Stadium Attendance: 1,004 Referee: Muhammad Hassan

May 18 11	Indy Eleven	4–1	Hartford Athletic	Indianapolis, IN
7:00 PM EDT	Blake pen' (3) Williams 11' Diz Pe 15' Ofeimu 45+3' Martínez 54' Williams 58'	Report	Ngalina 80' Vancaeyezeele 82'	Stadium: Carroll Stadium Attendance: 10,021 Referee: Elton García

May 25 12	Indy Eleven	2–1	Phoenix Rising	Indianapolis, IN
7:00 PM EDT	Blake pen' (26) Lindley 41' Boudadi 45+2' Blake 57' Blake 64' E. O'Brien 90'	Report	Hernández 19' Hernández 27' Scearce 32' Wyke 50' Ríos Novo 62'	Stadium: Carroll Stadium Attendance: 10,066 Referee: Calin Radosav

June 1 13	Pittsburgh Riverhounds	1–2	Indy Eleven	Pittsburgh, PA
7:00 PM EDT	Griffin 57' Diene 90+3'	Report	O'Brien 23' O'Brien 39' Guenzatti 46' Stanley 51' Mines 59' Collier 90+2'	Stadium: Highmark Stadium Attendance: 5,002 Referee: Lorenzo Hernandez

June 9 14	Birmingham Legion	0–1	Indy Eleven	Birmingham, AL
7:00 PM EDT		Report	Blake pen' (34)	Stadium: Protective Stadium Attendance: 5,147 Referee: Natalie Simon

June 15 15	Indy Eleven	1–0	San Antonio FC	Indianapolis, IN
7:00 PM EDT	Ofeimu 2' Burks 29' (o.g.) Mines 52' Chapman-Page 79' Blake 88'	Report	Hernández 16' Taintor 32' Chol 50' Gomez 54'	Stadium: Carroll Stadium Attendance: 10,491 Referee: Adam Kilpatrick

June 22 16	Indy Eleven	0–1	Orange County	Indianapolis, IN
7:00 PM EDT	Ofeimu 45+8' R. Williams 52'	Report	Zubak 25' Sorto 35' Zubak 42' Chattha 73'	Stadium: Carroll Stadium Attendance: 9,490 Referee: Joe Surgan

July 5 17	Rhode Island FC	3–3	Indy Eleven	Smithfield, RI
7:30 PM EDT	Nodarse 19' Nodarse 52', 69' Williams 80' Kwizera 84' Angking 90+5'	Report	Wootton 20' Collier 28' Mines 35' Sulte 52' O'Brien 59' Gibson 79'	Stadium: Beirne Stadium Attendance: 4,728 Referee: Ricardo Montero

July 13 18	Indy Eleven	1–1	Loudoun United	Indianapolis, IN
7:00 PM EDT	Chapman-Page 28' R. Williams 46' Collier 74'	Report	Leggett 58' Ryan 63'	Stadium: Carroll Stadium Attendance: 9,672 Referee: Brandon Stevis

July 20 19	Indy Eleven	0–2	Tampa Bay Rowdies	Indianapolis, IN
7:00 PM EDT	Wooton 33'	Report	Crisostomo 13' Jennings 36' Rivera 80'	Stadium: Carroll Stadium Attendance: 10,636 Referee: Thomas Snyder

July 26 20	FC Tulsa	0–0	Indy Eleven	Tulsa, OK
8:30 PM EDT	Goodrum 26' Laszo 47' St Clair 52'	Report	Chapman-Page 27' Diz 58' O'Brien 72' Ofeimu 79'	Stadium: ONEOK Field Attendance: 3,490 Referee: Lorenzo Hernandez

August 2 21	Charleston Battery	5–0	Indy Eleven	Mount Pleasant, SC
7:30 PM EDT	Myers 52' Ycaza 70' Markanich 78' Conway 85' Crawford 90+5'	Report	A. Williams 51' Diz Pe 67' Neidlinger 77'	Stadium: Patriots Point Soccer Complex Attendance: 2,845 Referee: Joshua Encarnación

August 7 22	Indy Eleven	1–0	Rhode Island FC	Indianapolis, IN
7:00 PM EDT	Guenzatti 34' Martínez 37' Guenzatti 50' Diz Pe 90+5'	Report	Stoneman 44'	Stadium: Carroll Stadium Attendance: 8,091 Referee: Ricardo Fierro

August 11 23	Indy Eleven	1–3	New Mexico United	Indianapolis, IN
5:00 PM EDT	Quinn 27' Neidlinger 28' Diz Pe 61' Chapman-Page 78'	Report	Rivas 27' Houssou 27' Ryden 45+2' Swartz 53' Rivas 64' Hurst 75' Hurst 90+4'	Stadium: Carroll Stadium Attendance: 10,013 Referee: Adam Kilpatrick

August 24 24	Las Vegas Lights	3–2	Indy Eleven	Las Vegas, NV
10:30 PM EDT	Ngando 2' Arozarena 21' Ngando 33' Noël 43' Bennett 45+4' Nigro 54'	Report	Guenzatti 26' Collier 45+3' Mines 56'	Stadium: Cashman Field Attendance: 4.532 Referee: Trevor Wiseman

August 31 25	Indy Eleven	1–1	Pittsburgh Riverhounds	Indianapolis, IN
7:00 PM EDT	Martínez 34' Lindley 71' R. Williams 72' R. Williams 90+7'	Report	Hogan 4' Mertz 66' Griffin 73'	Stadium: Carroll Stadium Attendance: 10,319 Referee: Elijio Arreguin

September 7 26	Hartford Athletic	0–0	Indy Eleven	Hartford, CT
7:00 PM EDT		Report	Blake 59' White 72'	Stadium: Trinity Health Stadium Attendance: 5,283 Referee: Thomas Snyder

September 14 27	Indy Eleven	3–1	El Paso Locomotive	Indianapolis, IN
7:00 PM EDT	R. Williams 12' Foster 49' White 58' Collier 77' Lindley 90'+6'	Report	Alfaro 63' Zacarías 83' Coronado 86' 90'+3' Lyons 86' 90'+4' Dollenmayer 88'	Stadium: Carroll Stadium Attendance: 10,132 Referee: Sergii Demianchuk

September 21 28	North Carolina FC	2–0	Indy Eleven	Cary, NC
7:30 PM EDT	Mentzingen 19' Maldonado 22' Batista 45+7' Mentzingen 55' Martin 73' Anderson 77' Anderson 79'	Report	R. Williams 33' White 45'	Stadium: WakeMed Soccer Park Attendance: 2,478 Referee: Jeremy Scheer

September 28 29	Indy Eleven	4–0	Miami FC	Indianapolis, IN
7:00 PM EDT	Quinn 42' Blake pen' (62) A. Williams 73', 84', 86', 87' Diz Pe 77' Soumaoro 87'	Report	Gavilanes 25' Knutson 60' Ndiaye 77' Palacios 90+1'	Stadium: Carroll Stadium Attendance: 10,145 Referee: Matthew Thompson

October 5 30	Indy Eleven	2–2	Louisville City	Indianapolis, IN
7:00 PM EDT	Quinn 4' Foster 20' A. Williams 45+3', 68'	Report	Dia 12' McFadden 29' Serrano 44' Adams 85' Morris 90+4'	Stadium: Carroll Stadium Attendance: 10,780 Referee: Alyssa Nichols

October 8 31	Loudoun United	0–1	Indy Eleven	Leesburg, VA
7:00 PM EDT	Johnston 16' Fauroux 53' Leerman 58' Tingey 63'	Report	Martínez 53' Mines 67' Musa 83' Diz Pe 85'	Stadium: Segra Field Attendance: 1,787 Referee: Abdou Ndiaye

October 12 32	Detroit City	0–0	Indy Eleven	Hamtramck, MI
4:00 PM EDT	Murphy 39' Diop 69' Rodriguez 78'	Report	Soumaoro 57' Musa 69'	Stadium: Keyworth Stadium Attendance: 6,240 Referee: Gerald Flores

October 19 33	Indy Eleven	3–2	Birmingham Legion	Indianapolis, IN
7:00 PM EDT	Kavita 14' (o.g.) Blake 15' A. Williams 79' Wootton 86'	Report	Pinho 54' Zouhir 90'	Stadium: Carroll Stadium Attendance: 10,540 Referee: Matthew Corrigan

October 26 34	Tampa Bay Rowdies	3–0	Indy Eleven	Bradenton, FL
7:30 PM EDT	Arteaga pen' (9) Chrisostomo 25' Hilton 50' Jennings 63' Munjoma 73' Worth 90+2'	Report	Chapman-Page 52'	Stadium: IMG Academy Soccer Stadium Attendance: 496 Referee: Calin Radosav

USL Cup Playoffs

The top eight teams in each USL Championship conference advanced to the 2024 USL Championship Playoffs. The Eleven qualified for the playoffs following a 3–2 home win over Birmingham Legion FC on October 19.^[12] The team secured a home game in the Conference Quarterfinals and a guaranteed top 4 conference finish on October 23 following Rhode Island FC's draw against Charleston Battery.^[13] The Eleven lost 2–3 at home to Rhode Island FC in the Conference Quarterfinals on November 3.^[14]

Conference Quarterfinals
November 1–3

Conference Semifinals
November 9–10

Conference Finals
November 16

USL Championship Final
November 23

E1

Louisville City FC

3

E8

North Carolina FC

2

E1

Louisville City FC

0

E5

Rhode Island FC

3

E4

Indy Eleven

2

E5

Rhode Island FC

3

E5

Rhode Island FC

Eastern Conference

E2

Charleston Battery

E3

Detroit City FC

1 (1)

E6

Tampa Bay Rowdies (p)

1 (3)

E6

Tampa Bay Rowdies

1

E2

Charleston Battery

2

E2

Charleston Battery

1

E7

Pittsburgh Riverhounds SC

0

W1

New Mexico United

2

W8

Phoenix Rising FC

1

W1

New Mexico United

0

W4

Las Vegas Lights FC

1

W4

Las Vegas Lights FC (p)

0 (3)

W5

Sacramento Republic FC

0 (2)

W4

Las Vegas Lights FC

Western Conference

W2

Colorado Springs Switchbacks FC

W3

Memphis 901 FC

0

W6

Orange County SC (a.e.t.)

1

W6

Orange County SC

1

W2

Colorado Springs Switchbacks FC (a.e.t.)

2

W2

Colorado Springs Switchbacks FC

2

W7

Oakland Roots SC

0

Playoff results

November 3 Conference Quarterfinals	Indy Eleven	2–3	Rhode Island FC	Indianapolis, IN
1:00 PM EDT	Quinn 35' Martínez 45+2' Foster 58' Musa 69' Martínez 78' Ofeimu 90+2'	Report	Williams pen' (19), 38', 52' Herivaux 81'	Stadium: Carroll Stadium Attendance: 7,623 Referee: Joshua Encarnación

U.S. Open Cup

As a member of the USL Championship, Indy Eleven entered the U.S. Open Cup tournament in the third round.^[15] The Eleven qualified for the Round of 32 for the first time since 2016 with a 1–0 victory over the Chicago Fire FC II on April 17, the team's first away victory in the U.S. Open Cup and their first shutout of the season.^[16]

The draw for the Round of 32 took place on April 18, with the Eleven hosting fellow USL Championship club San Antonio FC at home on May 8. On April 18, the Eleven announced that the match against San Antonio would be played at the Bud and Jackie Sellick Bowl on the campus of Butler University in Indianapolis.^[17]

The Eleven defeated San Antonio 2–0 on May 8 to advance to the Round of 16 for the first time in their history. In the Round of 16 on May 22, the Eleven defeated fellow USL Championship club Detroit City FC 3–0, who had defeated MLS side Houston Dynamo in the Round of 32.^[18]^[19]^[20]

The Eleven faced MLS side Atlanta United in the Quarter-finals on July 9, the first ever meeting of the two teams and Indy's first ever appearance in the Open Cup Quarter-finals.^[21] The Eleven's 2–1 victory was the team's first ever win over an MLS side, and advanced the team to a historic semi-final matchup.^[22]^[23] Indy Eleven's tournament ended in a 0–2 away loss to Sporting Kansas City on August 27 in the Eastern Semi-final.^[24] The Eleven were the only non-MLS team to reach the semi-finals and the result is the team's best-ever performance in the tournament.^[25]^[26]

Match results

April 17 Third round	Chicago Fire FC II	0–1	Indy Eleven	Bridgeview, IL
8:00 PM EDT	Glasgow 73' Rochester 80'	Report	Martínez 4' Ofeimu 31' Schneider 67' Diz Pe 67' Gibson 85'	Stadium: SeatGeek Stadium Attendance: 326 Referee: Peter Bernardy

May 8 Round of 32	Indy Eleven	2–0	San Antonio FC	Indianapolis, IN
7:00 PM EDT	A. Williams 2' Blake 10' Guenzatti 58'	Report	Hernández 20' Chol 41' Burks 66' Lacey 69'	Stadium: Sellick Bowl Attendance: 4,086 Referee: Kyle Johnston

May 22 Round of 16	Indy Eleven	3–0	Detroit City FC	Indianapolis, IN
7:00 PM EDT	Ofeimu 7' Carroll 14' (o.g.) A. Williams 33' Ofeimu 36' Blake 65' Schneider 90+1'	Report	Amoo-Mensah 61'	Stadium: Carroll Stadium Referee: Yosuke Araki

July 9 Quarterfinals	Atlanta United	1–2	Indy Eleven	Kennesaw, GA
7:00 PM EDT	Wiley 48' Firmino 90+2'	Report	A. Williams 31' Martínez 52' McCarty 83' (o.g.)	Stadium: Fifth Third Stadium Attendance: 2,417 Referee: Sergii Demianchuk

August 27 Semifinals	Sporting Kansas City	2–0	Indy Eleven	Kansas City, Kansas
10:00 PM EDT	Russell 14' Rosero 35' Sallói 68' Pulido 90+6'	Report	Quinn 19'	Stadium: Children's Mercy Park Attendance: 10,812 Referee: Rosendo Mendoza

Statistics

Appearances and goals

As of October 26, 2024.^[27]

No.	Pos	Nat	Player	Total		USLC		U.S. Open Cup
No.	Pos	Nat	Player	Apps	Goals	Apps	Goals	Apps	Goals
0	GK	USA	Hunter Sulte	31	0	27	0	4	0
1	GK	GER	Yannik Oettl	9	0	8	0	1	0
2	DF	IRL	Josh O'Brien	31	1	26	1	5	0
3	DF	USA	Aedan Stanley	39	0	34	0	5	0
5	DF	ENG	Callum Chapman-Page	19	0	17	0	2	0
6	MF	USA	Cam Lindley	34	0	30	0	4	0
7	FW	USA	Karsen Henderlong	6	0	6	0	0	0
8	MF	SCO	Jack Blake	32	10	28	9	4	1
9	FW	SLE	Augustine Williams	38	13	33	10	5	3
10	FW	JAM	Romario Williams	19	2	19	2	0	0
12	MF	USA	Diego Sanchez	3	0	2	0	1	0
13	FW	URU	Sebastian Guenzatti	33	5	29	5	4	0
14	MF	USA	Aodhan Quinn	13	1	12	1	1	0
15	DF	CUB	Adrian Diz Pe	32	1	29	1	3	0
16	MF	ENG	Laurence Wootton	28	2	24	2	4	0
18	FW	NZL	Elliot Collier	36	5	31	5	5	0
20	MF	USA	Ben Mines	26	0	22	0	4	0
21	MF	IRL	Ethan O'Brien	4	0	3	0	1	0
22	MF	USA	Tyler Gibson	24	1	21	1	3	0
24	GK	USA	Hayden Vostal	0	0	0	0	0	0
30	DF	USA	Ben Ofeimu	33	2	28	1	5	1
32	MF	LBR	Brem Soumaoro	9	0	9	0	0	0
33	DF	ENG	Hayden White	7	0	7	0	0	0
34	MID	GER	Max Schneider	11	0	7	0	4	0
37	DF	USA	Logan Neidlinger	17	1	16	1	1	0
39	MF	USA	Nikola Ivetic	0	0	0	0	0	0
41	DF	NZL	James Musa	9	1	8	1	1	0
42	FW	HON	Douglas Martinez	35	5	30	4	5	1
44	DF	ENG	Macauley King	3	0	2	0	1	0
46	GK	USA	Cayden Crawford	0	0	0	0	0	0
55	DF	USA	Maverick McCoy	0	0	0	0	0	0
99	FW	JAM	Maalique Foster	13	1	12	1	1	0
Players who left Indy during the season:
4	DF	USA	Danny Barbir	3	0	3	0	0	0
17	MF	USA	Tega Ikoba	12	1	9	1	3	0
23	DF	MAR	Younes Boudadi	9	0	8	0	1	0
30	DF	USA	Jay Klein	0	0	0	0	0	0
50	FW	SLV	Roberto Molina	5	0	5	0	0	0

Source: Indy stats

Disciplinary record

No.	Pos.	Name	USLC		Playoffs		U.S. Open Cup		Total
No.	Pos.	Name
0	GK	Hunter Sulte	1	0	0	0	0	0	1	0
1	GK	Yannik Oettl	1	0	0	0	0	0	1	0
2	DF	Josh O'Brien	4	0	0	0	0	0	4	0
3	DF	Aedan Stanley	3	0	0	0	0	0	3	0
5	DF	Callum Chapman-Page	8	0	0	0	0	0	8	0
6	MF	Cameron Lindley	6	0	0	0	0	0	6	0
7	FW	Karsen Henderlong	1	0	0	0	0	0	1	0
8	MF	Jack Blake	6	0	0	0	1	0	7	0
9	FW	Augustine Williams	4	0	0	0	0	0	4	0
10	FW	Romario Williams	5	0	0	0	0	0	5	0
13	FW	Sebastián Guenzatti	2	0	0	0	1	0	3	0
14	MF	Aodhan Quinn	3	0	0	0	1	0	4	0
15	DF	Adrián Diz Pe	7	2	0	0	1	0	8	2
16	MF	Laurence Wootton	1	0	0	0	0	0	1	0
17	FW	Tega Ikoba	1	0	0	0	0	0	1	0
18	FW	Elliot Collier	2	0	0	0	0	0	2	0
20	MF	Ben Mines	5	0	0	0	0	0	5	0
21	MF	Ethan O'Brien	1	0	0	0	0	0	1	0
22	MF	Tyler Gibson	1	0	0	0	1	0	2	0
23	DF	Younes Boudadi	3	0	0	0	0	0	3	0
30	DF	Ben Ofeimu	4	0	1	0	2	0	7	0
32	MF	Brem Soumaoro	2	0	0	0	0	0	2	0
33	DF	Hayden White	3	0	0	0	0	0	3	0
34	MF	Max Schneider	1	0	0	0	2	0	3	0
37	DF	Logan Neidlinger	1	0	0	0	0	0	1	0
41	DF	James Musa	1	0	1	0	0	0	2	0
42	FW	Douglas Martínez	6	0	1	0	1	0	8	0
44	DF	Macauley King	1	0	0	0	0	0	1	0
99	FW	Maalique Foster	1	0	1	0	0	0	2	0

Source: Indy Stats

Clean sheets

No.	Name	USLC	U.S. Open Cup	Total	Games Played
0	Hunter Sulte	9	2	11	31
1	Yannik Oettl	0	1	1	9
24	Hayden Vostal	0	0	0	0
46	Cayden Crawford	0	0	0	0

Source: Indy stats

Goals

Rank	No.	Name	USLC	Playoffs	U.S. Open Cup	Total	Games Played
1	9	Augustine Williams	10	0	3	13	38
2	8	Jack Blake	10	0	1	11	32
T-3	13	Sebastian Guenzatti	5	0	0	5	33
T-3	42	Douglas Martinez	3	1	1	5	35
T-3	18	Elliot Collier	5	0	0	5	36
T-6	10	Romario Williams	2	0	0	2	19
T-6	16	Laurence Wootton	2	0	0	2	28
T-6	30	Ben Ofeimu	1	0	1	2	33
T-9	41	James Musa	1	0	0	1	9
T-9	17	Tega Ikoba	1	0	0	1	12
T-9	14	Aodhan Quinn	0	1	0	1	13
T-9	99	Maalique Foster	1	0	0	1	13
T-9	37	Logan Neidlinger	1	0	0	1	17
T-9	22	Tyler Gibson	1	0	0	1	24
T-9	2	Josh O'Brien	1	0	0	1	31
T-9	15	Adrian Diz Pe	1	0	0	1	32

Source: Indy stats

Awards

USL Championship Team of the Week Selections
Week	Starters			Bench		Opponent(s)	Link
1	Jack Blake	Younes Boudadi				Oakland	[1]
2	Jack Blake	Aedan Stanley				Memphis	[2]
5	Jack Blake					Louisville	[3]
8				Callum Chapman-Page		North Carolina	[4]
9	Jack Blake			Adrian Diz Pe		Monterey Bay	[5]
10	Aedan Stanley	Adrian Diz Pe	A. Williams			Miami	[6]
11	Aedan Stanley			Younes Boudadi	Ben Ofeimu	Hartford	[7]
12	Jack Blake					Phoenix	[8]
13	Ben Ofeimu					Pittsburgh	[9]
15	Hunter Sulte					San Antonio	[10]
19				Ben Ofeimu		Loudoun	[11]
25	Jack Blake					Las Vegas	[12]
26				Ben Ofeimu		Pittsburgh	[13]
27				Adrian Diz Pe		Hartford	[14]
28	Jack Blake			Romario Williams	Maalique Foster	El Paso	[15]
30	A. Williams			Jack Blake		Miami	[16]
31	A. Williams					Louisville	[17]
32	Ben Ofeimu			Hunter Sulte		Loudoun, Detroit	[18]
33	Jack Blake					Birmingham	[19]