"Coney Island" is a song by the American singer-songwriter Taylor Swift featuring the American band the National. Swift, Joe Alwyn, and the brothers Aaron and Bryce Dessner wrote the song for Swift's ninth studio album, Evermore (2020). The track was produced by the Dessner brothers, and Matt Berninger contributed guest vocals. An alternative rock and indie folk track, "Coney Island" has lyrics depicting a separated couple's memories in Coney Island. Swift and Berninger respectively sings about their character's perspective reflecting on their past relationship.
Republic Records sent "Coney Island" to US adult album alternative radio as a single on January 18, 2021. While several critics praised the vocal chemistry of Swift and Berninger and picked the song as a highlight off Evermore, several others found the lyrics and production weak. "Coney Island" peaked at number 45 on the Billboard Global 200 and charted in Australia, Canada, and the United States. Swift performed "Coney Island" live twice on her sixth headlining concert tour, the Eras Tour (2023–2024).[1]
Background
Taylor Swift had collaborated with The National's Aaron Dessner on her 2020 album Folklore, an indie folk album that departs from the upbeat pop production of her previous releases.[2] She and Dessner worked again on her follow-up album Evermore, a "sister record" to Folklore. This time, they also worked with Bryce Dessner, Aaron Dessner's twin brother.[3]
The Dessner brothers sent Swift some of the instrumentals they made for their band, The National. One of those was what would become "Coney Island". Swift and her then-boyfriend, English actor Joe Alwyn, wrote its lyrics, and recorded it with her vocals. After listening to the demo, the Dessner brothers observed that the song feels very related to The National, and envisioned Matt Berninger (lead vocalist of The National) singing it, and Bryan Devendorf (drummer of The National) playing its drums. Aaron Dessner informed Berninger, who was "excited" for the idea. The band assembled, Devendorf played the drums, while his brother Scott Devendorf played the bass and pocket piano; Bryce Dessner helped produce the song.[3]
Composition and lyrics
"Coney Island" is an alternative rock and indie folk song[4] written in the waltz tempo.[5][6] The song features The National, with frontman Matt Berninger on vocals. Berninger said that work experience with Swift was "like dancing with Gene Kelly. She made [him] look good and didn't drop [him] once". The lyrics are about the hollow feelings of losing oneself in a relationship that has gone.[7]
Critical reception
Spin critic Bobby Olivier described "Coney Island" as a "wonderfully dark duet" that feels like "a lonely waltz down a Brooklyn boardwalk", and praised the fusion of Swift's "wispy" head voice with Berninger's bass.[8] Chris Willman of Variety compared the song to "Exile" (2020), another similar duet on Swift's preceding album, where former lovers take turns in blaming each other, with the opposite happening in "Coney Island".[9] Neil McCormick of The Daily Telegraph wrote that the song "offers an insight into where their aesthetics meet", counterpointing Swift's "lucid, melodious voice" aside "the mumbled intensity" of Berninger's baritone.[10]
Tom Breihan of Stereogum called "Coney Island" the "dourest" moment of Evermore, alike "The Last Time" in Swift's fourth studio album, Red (2012).[11] Craig Jenkins of Vulture complimented Berninger's baritone and Swift's delicate vocals: "you hear [the song] and you start to wonder if the low end notes on these albums are another bout of trying out other singer-songwriters' wares".[12] In less favourable reviews, The Guardian'sAlexis Petridis welcomed the guest appearance of Berninger, but found the lyrics to be "subpar" without "much substance".[13]Pitchfork's Sam Sodomsky opined that Berninger's vocals felt out of place on the song.[14] It was deemed one of the album's weaker tracks by Slate's Carl Wilson.[15]