The then American commander William Hull of the United States Army, surrendered the fort in 1812, shortly after War was declared in June 1812 by the United States Congress and approved by the fourth President, James Madison (17xx-1836, served 1809-1817). But it was reclaimed by the U.S. military forces the following year in 1813. The Americans renamed it Fort Shelby then in 1813, but occasional references to "Fort Detroit" relating to the War of 1812 period of 1812-1815, are to this fort.
The earlier Fort Detroit, built by the Royal French for their New France colony from Quebec city in the interior of North America, around the Great Lakes, as part of their then world-wide First French Empire and occupied by them during the Seven Years War / French and Indian War of 1753-1763 in America, After the loss of French territories and their New France and Louisiana and Canada possessions in North America in the Treaty of Paris of 1763, the British Army reoccupied all the fortifications and reigned supreme on the continent for the next two decades. But Detroit was later abandoned by the British 16 years later in 1779, during the American Revolutionary War (1775-1783), in favor of Fort Lernoult. Fort Shelby was later returned to and occupied finally by the United States after Jay's Treaty of 1796, negotiations and ratification further settled outstanding issues with the former Mother Country, including continued British occupation of border fortifications on American soil, a decade after the Revolutionary War ended, despite the terms of the subsequent peace of the second Treaty of Paris of 1783, recognizing the Independence of the United States. The site was given later to the surrounding city of Detroit in 1826 and was dismantled the following year in 1827.
History
Fort Lernoult under the British
In the fall of 1778, Captain Richard Lernoult, the commander of the British Army at Fort Detroit, feared that the existing encampment would not be sufficient to defend against the oncoming American forces. Under the command of Colonel Daniel Brodhead, they had advanced to within ninety miles. He dispatched his second in command, Captain Henry Bird, to plan a new fortification on higher ground. Work commenced on the project in November 1778, and although construction was beset by problems due to severe weather, by October 1779 a total of 381 British troops were stationed at the new fort.[2]
The fort was constructed of a 4' high pile of tree trunks, topped with 7–8' long sharpened stakes, all of which were covered with an 11' high earth embankment, 12' wide at the top and 26' thick at the base. Outside of the embankment was a 5–6' deep ditch, 12' wide and containing an 11–12' picket.[2]
On August 5, 1805, Secretary of WarHenry Dearborn sent a letter to Fort Lernoult's commander, Samuel Dyson, informing him that the fort's name had been changed to Fort Detroit.[4]Michigan TerritoryGovernorWilliam Hull expanded the fort in 1807, building a higher (14 feet) stockade.[5] Upon the outbreak of hostilities with the British in 1812, Hull was named a brigadier general and placed in command of the Army of the Northwest. Hull left Fort Lernoult on July 12, 1812, to undertake an invasion of Canada, which was abandoned after he learned that the British had captured the island Fort Mackinac.
General William Hull
Following Hull's retreat to the other side of the Detroit River, British General Isaac Brock set up artillery batteries in what is now Windsor, Ontario, directly opposite the fort. According to Brock's later report, the attacking force included 600 warriors and 1300 soldiers, as well as two warships.[6] On the morning of August 15, 1812, Brock sent a demand to Hull, with an implicit threat of massacre at the hands of his Indian allies:
Sir, The force at my disposal authorizes me to require of you the immediate surrender of Fort Detroit. It is far from my inclination to join in a war of extermination, but you must be aware that the numerous body of Indians, who have attached themselves to my troops, will be beyond my control the moment the contest commences.[7]
Hull initially refused to surrender, replying:
Sir, I have received your letter of this date. I have no other reply to make, than to inform you that I am prepared to meet any force which may be at your disposal, and any consequences, which may result from any exertion of it you may think proper to make.[7]
Wikisource has original text related to this article:
The following morning, under cover from their batteries as well as the ships HMS Queen Charlotte and HMS Hunter, the British crossed the Detroit River and began advancing on the fort.[8] As casualties began to rise, and fearing slaughter at the hands of the Indians, Hull surrendered the fort and all of its weapons, as well as two detachments of troops under the command of Colonels Lewis Cass and Duncan McArthur that were returning to the fort. General Hull was court-martialed for surrendering the fort without a fight, and sentenced to be shot, but he was pardoned by President James Madison.
The fort remained in British hands for over a year, until the Battle of Lake Erie. Following their defeat in the naval battle, and with General William Henry Harrison advancing on Detroit with 1,000 troops, the British retreated to the Canadian side of the river. Duncan McArthur, by then a general, took possession of the fort on September 29, 1813, and the fort was renamed Fort Shelby in honor of Governor Isaac Shelby of Kentucky, who had come to the aid of General Harrison with a regiment of volunteers.[5]
The fort was occupied for the next 13 years, but fell into disrepair. Congress gave it to the city of Detroit in 1826, and it was demolished in the spring of 1827.[9]
The site today
Fort location overlaid on modern street map.
The fort was centered on the present-day intersection of Fort Street and Shelby Street in downtown Detroit, and bounded by Michigan Avenue, Griswold Street, W. Congress Street, and Cass Avenue. While excavating in 1961 to build the Detroit Bank & Trust Building, the remains of a wooden post from the fort were discovered. A total of over 8,000 artifacts were retrieved and are now housed at the Anthropology Museum at Wayne State University.[10]
^Sources vary in their opinion as to whether the fort was renamed Fort Detroit by the Americans or was simply commonly called by that name. (Collins 2006, p. 36) says, "The fort's name was never popular, and invariably it was referred to as simply 'Detroit'" until it was renamed specifically Fort Shelby. The State of Michigan's Historical Marker on the site says, "In 1812, Fort Lernoult was surrendered to the British Army, but was regained by the Americans in 1813 and re-named Fort Shelby."[1] Meanwhile, (Woodford & Woodford 1969, p. 72) says, "When the Americans took over, it was renamed Fort Detroit and so was known until after the War of 1812 when it became Fort Shelby." (Clements 1990, p. 368) cites an August 5, 1805, letter from Henry Dearborn to the commander of the fort stating that its name had been changed to Fort Detroit. This article takes that letter as authoritative.
