Critic from the Josh at the Movies gave it 2.5/5 stars writing: "The compiled talent for Horror Noire is the biggest draw here; unfortunately, the stories themselves are quite a mixed bag."[3] Chris Catt from the Creepy Catalog gave it a positive review and noted the final segment, “Sundown”.[4] Joel Fisher from the Battle Royale With Cheese also gave it a positive review writing: "Horror Noire is a unique perspective on horror and for those aficionados of the genre then they may even have fun finding the references within."[5]