This section needs expansion. You can help by adding to it. (April 2019)
Lance debuted on April 3, 2010 winning a match for a show promoted by the National Wrestling League vs. Chrono Chris in Martinsburg, West Virginia.[3] He was in World Xtreme Wrestling which is owned by his grandfather, Afa Anoaʻi. He often was involved in matches with his kins Samu, Afa Jr. and Sean Maluta.
Lance wrestled for Maryland Championship Wrestling (MCW), debuting in August 2012. Lance made his debut for Pro Wrestling Syndicate (PWS) in 2012. At Supercard 2013, Lance was involved in a battle royal for the number-one contender for the PWS Heavyweight Championship on Night 1 and on Night 2, Lance had a match with Sonjay Dutt. Lance competed for the PWS Tri State Championship in a Six Way Match at PWS Return to Rahway on September 20, 2013, that included Craven Varro, Starman, Facade, Pat Buck and The Drunken Swashbuckler. At the Shane Shamrock Memorial Cup 2013, he fought Luke Hawx on August 10, 2013, and lasted until the semi-finals.
On March 3, 2018, he made his debut with Major League Wrestling (MLW) at their event "Spring Break".[5] In the match, he lost to Maxwell Jacob Friedman.[6] In July 2018 he participated in the first-ever Battle Riot at the namesake event, which was won by Tom Lawlor.[7] In October 2018, he started teaming with his father Samu in MLW as The Samoan Island Tribe.[8] In early 2019 he would feud with Rich Swann resulting in losses in singles and tag team matches. In April 2019, he competed in the second Battle Riot, again unsuccessfully.[9]
On the January 2, 2015 edition of WWE SmackDown, he teamed with Rhett Titus in a losing effort against The Ascension.[13] On February 1, 2017, he competed in a losing effort at a WWE NXT event against The Authors of Pain.[1][14] This appearance was related to a tryout he was having with WWE. In April 2019, he fought at another WWE tryout.[4] On the May 27, 2019, show of WWE Raw, Anoa'i faced Shane McMahon representing the Anoaʻi family. He would lose the match by submission, after Drew McIntyre attacked him. After the match he was beat down by McMahon and McIntyre, before Roman Reigns made the save.[15]
NXT (2024–present)
It was reported that Anoa'i has signed with WWE in the summer of 2024 and has been assigned to its NXT brand.[16] He has yet to make his debut due to an injury.[17]