Non-resident citizen voting is citizens voting in elections according to their citizenship while not residing in the country of the election. As of 2020 a total of 141 countries grant non-residents such as emigrants or expatriates the right to non-resident citizen voting.[1] There is considerable variation across countries in regard to voter eligibility, voting modalities, i.e. voting in person at diplomatic missions or other physical locations, by post or online, which elections nonresident citizens may vote in, i.e. elections of the national legislature, executive elections, referendums, or sub-national elections, and how nonresident citizen voters are represented. The number of countries enfranchising nonresident citizens accelerated significantly in the 1990s. Social scientists have advanced a number of claims about the causes and consequences of this development and debated its normative implications or pros and cons of nonresident citizen voting.
Variations
Some countries (such as France) grant their expatriate citizens unlimited voting rights, identical to those of citizens living in their home country.[2] Other countries allow expatriate citizens to vote only for a certain number of years after leaving the country, after which they are no longer eligible to vote (e.g. 25 years for Germany, except if you can show that you are still affected by the political decisions in Germany). Other countries reserve the right vote solely to citizens living in that country, thereby stripping expatriate citizens of their voting rights once they leave their home country (such as Ireland, with extremely limited exceptions).
There is similar variation in how non-resident citizens can exercise their right to vote. Most commonly, non-resident voters have to cast their ballots at an embassy or consulate of their country. Some countries are even more restrictive, such as East Timor which "limited in-person voting to only its Australian and Portuguese missions in 2017."[3] At the less restrictive end of the spectrum non-resident New Zealand voters may download their ballots and upload their completed ballots to the Electoral Commission's website or mail in or fax their ballots to the New Zealand Electoral Commission or a New Zealand diplomatic mission.[4]
French non-resident citizen voters may cast ballots in elections for the European Parliament, French presidential elections, national referendums as well as elections to the National Assembly, the lower house of parliament, and elections for members of the Assembly of French Citizens Resident Abroad who in turn elect 12 members of the French Senate.[2] New Zealand non-resident citizen voters may cast their ballots in national as well as local elections. In Colombia non-resident citizens may vote in presidential and legislative elections, but they are excluded from regional and local elections.[5]
Finally, some countries assimilate non-resident voters into existing constituencies for resident citizens whereas others have reserved special seats in their legislatures for non-resident citizen voters. The United States is an example of the first alternative. United States citizens who live abroad may vote in the state where they have established voting residence, and their votes will count toward election results in that state.[6]Italy, on the other hand, established special seats in the Italian Senate and the Chamber of Deputies to represent non-resident citizens.
Historical development
According to a pioneering study by the International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance, the first case of external voting took place in the United States in the state of Wisconsin in 1862 when the state allowed absentee voting by soldiers fighting in the Civil War.[7] The United Kingdom also allowed absentee voting for soldiers in 1918.[7] After WWII Indonesia adopted legislation in 1953 which allowed not just military personnel or other public servants but also migrant workers and students to vote from abroad.[7] The biggest expansion of external voting occurred in the 1990s.[8]
Causes and consequences
There are a number of different reasons which explain why and when states enfranchise non-resident citizens. One factor is that states seek benefits from emigrants, i.e. states hope that emigrants will be more likely to contribute to the economy of their country of origin through remittances or show loyalty in other ways if they have the right to vote in that country's elections.[9] Second, the enfranchisement of non-resident citizens may be the result of lobbying by emigrant organizations. This played a role in the Mexican case.[9] Third, governing parties will resist non-resident citizen voting if they have grounds to believe that extending the franchise will benefit the opposition. Thus, non-resident citizen voting becomes possible once the opponents of non-resident citizen voting lose power as happened in Italy in the 1990s.[9] Finally, Turcu and Urbatch found evidence for the diffusion of democratic norms favoring non-resident citizen voting.[10] Once one country introduces non-resident citizen voting, neighboring countries become more likely to do the same.
Normative debates
Political theorists and legal scholars have debated the merits of and problems with non-resident citizen voting. Political theorist and citizenship scholar Rainer Bauböck has evaluated a number of arguments in favor of non-resident citizen voting.[11] First, in a democracy all citizens beyond the minimum age requirement should have the right to vote, and non-resident citizens are still citizens and thus should have the right to vote.[11] Second, non-resident citizens make important economic contributions to their countries of origin, and the value of these contributions should be recognized by offering them the right to vote.[11] Ultimately, Rainer Bauböck favors a third approach centered around the concept of stakeholder community. He proposes the "[i]ndividuals whose circumstances of life link their future well-being to the flourishing of a particular polity should be recognized as stakeholders in that polity with a claim to participate in collective decision-making processes that shape the shared future of this political community" (page 2422).[11] Thus, the first generation should be allowed to vote in elections in their countries of origin. According to Rainer Bauböck, this privilege should not automatically be extended to the second or subsequent generations.[11]
The legal scholar Ruth Rubio Marin is more critical of proposals to extend voting rights to non-resident citizens.[12] She argues that "[a]bsentee voting is an option that, under certain circumstances, sending countries may legitimately embrace; it is not a right that diasporic national communities can simply assert" (page 145).[12]
By jurisdiction
Australia
Australian citizens living abroad may vote if they register to vote within three years of leaving and intend to return to Australia within six years of leaving. Australians who were under 18 when they left Australia may vote if they intend to return to Australia within six years of their 18th birthday. Voting may be done by post or at an Australian embassy, consulate or high commission. Unlike for Australians living in Australia, voting is not compulsory for expatriate Australians.[13]
For the 2023 Australian Indigenous Voice referendum, overseas voting centres were operational at Australian diplomatic offices in 80 countries and territories. While most countries and territories only had one polling place, multiple were available for voters in Brazil (2), Canada (3), China (4, excluding Hong Kong), Germany (2), India (5), Indonesia (4), Italy (2), Japan (2), New Zealand (2), Papua New Guinea (2), Switzerland (2), Turkey (2), the United Arab Emirates (2), the United States (7) and Vietnam (2).[14] Additionally, telephone voting was available for Australian citizens in Antarctica.[15]
For state and territory elections, the availability of overseas polling places is limited, though interstate polling places are operational for state and territory elections in every state and territory. In New South Wales, voters living or travelling overseas must vote by post unless they are able to vote at an in-person early voting centre in New Zealand.[16] In other jurisdictions, overseas voters normally have to either vote by post or vote online.
Austria
Austrian citizens living abroad may vote by post in Austrian presidential and parliamentary elections, as well as referendums, with no expiry date. They must enrol on a dedicated foreign voters' register and must renew their registration every ten years.[17]
As of 2017, Belgian citizens living abroad can register to vote for elections to the Chamber of Representatives and the European Parliament. Once registered in a consular post (which is optional), the person is subject to compulsory voting. Expatriates cannot vote in regional or local elections.
The very first legislation regarding eligible Belgians abroad was implemented during 1919–25 to accommodate Belgian military stationed in German territories after World War I. Their votes were cast on an earlier date and sent to their corresponding electoral district in Belgium.[18]
The first modern law, the law of 18 December 1998, gave Belgians living abroad the right to vote in federal elections (i.e. for the Chamber and Senate). However, the law was inadequate[clarification needed] and not generally applied.
The law of 7 March 2002 improved the procedure. Belgians abroad could register in a municipality of their choice, determining the constituency in which their vote would be cast. In practice, most votes were cast in the linguistically sensitive Brussels-Halle-Vilvoorde constituency.
The sixth Belgian state reform (ca. 2012), which also abolished the Brussels-Halle-Vilvoorde constituency and direct Senate elections, replaced the free choice by an objectively defined municipality (where the person last lived, or else further criteria apply).
The law of 17 November 2016 slightly changed the procedure, and also extended the right to vote for European Parliament elections to Belgians living in a non-EU member state. Belgians living in another EU member state already had the right to vote on Belgian lists in European Parliament elections.
On 26 August 2016, the cabinet also approved the right to vote in regional elections; however, this change is subject to approval by special majority in parliament, causing the measure to stall.
Brazil
Brazilian citizens living abroad aged between 18 and 70 must vote, as Brazil's policy of compulsory voting includes expatriate Brazilians.[19] Voting is possible, but not mandatory, for Brazilian expatriates aged over 70 or under 18 (Brazil's minimum voting age is 16). Brazilian voters abroad cast ballots only for presidential elections.[20]
Canada
Per Bill C-76,[21] Canadian expatriates may vote in federal elections by post or in person, no matter how long they've lived outside the country.
Previously, Canadian law dictated that citizens living abroad could only vote by post if they had lived outside the country for less than five consecutive years (citizens that worked for the Canadian government, a Canadian company or an international organisation in which Canada was involved were exempt from this rule).[22] On 11 January 2019, the Supreme Court of Canada, after deliberating the case of Frank v Canada[23] for which the Ontario Court of Appeal had upheld these restrictions,[24] struck down the restrictions. The Supreme Court of Canada ruling affirmed the rights of long-term expats to vote.[25][26]
Citizens living abroad have always maintained their eligibility to vote in person if possible.
Chile
Chilean expatriates have the right to vote in presidential elections (primaries, first and second round) and national referendums in the consulate where they registered.[27][28] The law allowing expatriate Chilean citizens the right to vote was presented by President Michelle Bachelet and approved by Congress in August 2016. The primaries for the 2017 presidential election were the first time that expatriates were allowed to vote.
Colombia
Regardless of their time living abroad, Colombian expatriates enjoy full voting rights in national referendums, presidential and parliamentary elections. One member of the House of Representatives comes from the international constituency and is elected exclusively by citizens living abroad. In order to vote, Colombian citizens have to register in their respective consulate or embassy in the established periods before the election dates.[29]
Costa Rica
Costa Rican citizens can vote for president and national referendums regardless of their time living abroad since Electoral Code's reform of 2010. They can't, however, vote in local elections which includes deputies and municipal authorities. The first time this was implemented was in the 2014 Costa Rican general election. Costa Ricans vote in the respective consulate or embassy and have to register their location a year before the election.[30][31]
Czech Republic
Czech citizens living abroad may participate in parliamentary elections.[32] Their votes must be cast at polling stations. For the 2021 election, Czech expats are trying to raise awareness of the difficulty to attend polling stations to call for the ability to vote by post.[33]
Denmark
Danish citizens who leave Denmark may vote in parliamentary elections, referendums and EU Parliament elections (but not local elections) for two years after their move, after which they are disenfranchised unless and until they move back. There are exceptions granting indefinite overseas voting rights for certain categories of expatriates, primarily those working for the Danish government or on job assignments for Danish employers.
For EU Parliament elections, Danish citizens living in EU countries may continue to vote indefinitely.[34]
Danes Worldwide wishes to improve voting rights for citizens abroad, and favors amending the Constitution to do so.[35] In 2024, longtime Danish politician Bertel Haarder publicly endorsed this position.[36]
Dominican Republic
Dominican citizens abroad can vote for presidential and legislative elections. Seven seats in the Chamber of Deputies are reserved for the expat community, with three of them corresponding to the United States and Canada, two to Latin America and the Caribbean and another two to Europe. This is contemplated in the constitution since 2010 and was first implemented in the 2012 Dominican presidential election.[37]
Finnish citizens living abroad are eligible to vote in Parliamentary elections and presidential elections. They may also vote in the elections for the European Parliament provided they have not registered to vote in their country of residence.[41]
Article 12(2)(1) of the Federal Voting Act[42] states that German citizens who live abroad and have no residence in Germany may vote in German parliamentary elections and European Parliament elections if:
They have resided in Germany for an uninterrupted period of at least three months since their 14th birthday and within the last 25 years; or
They have a close personal and direct relationship with German politics and are personally affected by political developments in Germany.[43]
Expatriate Greek citizens are allowed to vote in home country elections under certain conditions.[45]
Hungary
In Hungary, there are in practice two types of expatriate citizens with different voting rights. Those who (still) have their main residence are considered who are temporarily abroad vote in their constituency with full voting rights in parliamentary, European and local elections, however may only to so in person in their precinct or at a consulate. Those who do not have their main residence in Hungary are considered settled in another country and have limited voting rights in parliamentary elections (only have a list vote, as they are without a constituency), but may vote by mail and may not vote in local elections. Provided non-resident citizens are residents of a non-EU country, they may vote for Hungarian lists in European elections, but residents of EU countries may only vote in their country of residence instead.
India
Expatriate Indian citizens have been allowed to vote in all Indian elections since 2010, provided that they have not acquired the citizenship of another country (India does not permit dual nationality).[46] However, overseas voters must be physically present at their original constituency to vote, making it infeasible for most expatriates to actually cast their votes.[47]
Indonesia
Eligible Indonesians living abroad are able to vote by mail or at diplomatic missions in national elections by registering at the Indonesian overseas election commission in their country of residence. Besides presidential elections, they are also able to vote in DPR elections. All overseas Indonesian voters are included in the Jakarta 2nd constituency, which also contains Central and South Jakarta.[48]
Israeli citizens may vote regardless of their current resident status. However, in practice, Israeli expats are required to travel to Israel in order to vote, because voting is only possible in ballot boxes, and ballot boxes are only set up in Israel and in the occupied Palestinian territories. (Voting outside of Israel is available to restricted groups of military and diplomatic personnel that are stationed outside of Israel.)[57][circular reference]
Italian citizens living abroad retain the right to vote in Italian parliamentary elections and referendums. They may vote either by post or at an Italian consulate or embassy. However, for Italian citizens who live in a country which has no Italian diplomatic representation, the only way to vote is to travel to Italy to vote in person. Citizens who choose to do so are reimbursed by the Italian government for 75% of their travel costs.[58]
The Italian Parliament reserves 12 seats for those citizens residing abroad: there are eight such seats in the Chamber of Deputies and four in the Senate of the Republic.
Japan
Japanese citizens living abroad have been allowed to vote in Dietelections since 2005, when the Supreme Court ruled that a ban on eligible overseas Japanese citizens from voting was unconstitutional. Citizens can vote either by post or at their local Japanese embassy or consulate.[59]
Maltese citizens may only vote if they have resided in Malta for at least six months in the previous eighteen months prior to registration in the electoral register.[64] Although the law clearly states a residency requirement, it is rarely enforced and hundreds of expatriate fly down to Malta to vote in Elections. There have been attempts and petitions to allow Maltese citizens living abroad to vote by post.[65]
Mexico
Starting in 2021, former residents are allowed to vote for an expatriate representative in the Mexico City Congress.[66]
Morocco
Only Moroccan citizens living in Morocco are able to vote in the elections.[67]
Namibia
Namibian citizens living abroad have been allowed to vote in national elections since 2014, when amendments were made to the Electoral Act 2009, Namibian expatriates may vote at temporary registration points, usually set up at Namibian embassies or high commissions.[68]
Netherlands
Dutch citizens who live abroad (and have deregistered as Dutch residents) are allowed to vote in elections for the House of Representatives and for the European Parliament, but cannot vote in municipal or provincial elections. They must register as voters in order to vote from abroad.
New Zealand
New Zealand citizens living abroad have full voting rights with no expiry date as long as they have lived in New Zealand for at least one year continuously at some point in their lives and have visited New Zealand within the last three years, while permanent residents are eligible to vote if they have visited the country in the past twelve months; in 2023 this was temporarily changed for the 2023 general election, with citizens being eligible if they had visited the country in the past six years, and permanent residents eligible if they had visited in the past four years.[69]
Nigeria
Nigerian citizens living abroad have full voting rights, however, these rights have not been enacted as the National Assembly and Independent National Electoral Commission are yet to come to an agreement on how to actualize expatriate voting. In 2021, Minister of State for Foreign Affairs Zubairu Dada reiterated the Government's intent to enact diaspora voting, albeit not in time for the 2023 Nigerian general election.[70]
Pakistan
The PTI government in 2018 made loose legislation on allowing Overseas Pakistani to be allowed to vote.
Such legislation did not consider aspects such as time spent abroad, remittances sent among others. They were allowed to register a vote by presenting NICOP, passport and an email address, which is criticized as Pakistani citizens within Pakistan were given no such right to vote in their constituency with such ease without physically being present at the booth. This legislation was removed by Shahbaz Sharif's coalition government and framework for Oversea Pakistani voting right pushed to future use.
Peru
Peruvian citizens living abroad aged between 18 and 70 must vote, as Peru's policy of compulsory voting includes expatriate Peruvians.[71] Nevertheless, the penalty fee for failing to vote is automatically waived for all Peruvians abroad. Voting is possible, but not mandatory, for Peruvian expatriates aged over 70.[71] Peruvian expatriates have the right to vote in presidential (first and second round) elections, congressional elections, and election for representative to the Andean Parliament as well as national referendums in the consulate where they are registered. As of 2021, two members of Congress come from the international constituency and are elected exclusively by citizens living abroad.[72]
Philippines
Under Republic Act No. 9189 (also known as the Overseas Absentee Voting Act of 2003), Filipino citizens living abroad are allowed to vote, with no expiry date.[73]
Portugal has a Council of Portuguese Communities (Conselho das Comunidades Portuguesas), a consultative body which is part of the Portuguese government and represents the interests of Portuguese citizens living abroad.[84]
4 seats of the Portuguese Parliament (out of 230) are reserved for those living abroad: 2 mandates allocated for Europe, the other 2 from outside Europe.
Romania
Romanian citizens living abroad may vote in presidential, parliamentary and European Parliament elections. For presidential elections, they can vote by registering for a postal vote or by going to a polling station abroad. In parliamentary elections, Romanians abroad are represented in Parliament by four members of the Chamber of Deputies and two members of the Senate.
Prior to 2023, they may only vote in person at one of ten designated overseas polling stations, located in various places such as Australia (Canberra), China (two polling stations: Beijing and Shanghai), Japan (Tokyo), Hong Kong, the United Arab Emirates (Dubai), the United Kingdom (London) and the United States (three polling stations: New York City, San Francisco and Washington, D.C.).[85] Each citizen is assigned to an overseas polling station depending on where they live. Expatriate citizens are also assigned a polling station in Singapore, where they can vote in person if they happen to be in Singapore on election day.[86]
In 2023, an amendment to the Presidential Elections Act and Parliamentary Elections Act was tabled in Parliament that enables Singaporeans living abroad to vote by post in subsequent elections, giving them an additional option.[87]
South Africa
Pursuant to the revised section 33 (3) and (4) of the Electoral Amendment Act 18 of 2013, South African citizens living abroad are able to exercise the right to vote in national elections, and are also able to register from outside the country.[88] Expatriate citizens who wish to vote must do so in person at a South African embassy, consulate or high commission. While South Africans abroad could initially only register in person at a diplomatic mission, as of 2023 they are able to register to vote online.[89]
Spain
Article 68, Section 5 of the Spanish Constitution guarantees Spanish citizens living abroad the right to vote. They may do so either at a Spanish consulate or embassy, or by post.[90]
Spain has a General Council of Spanish Citizenship Abroad (Consejo General de la Ciudadanía Española en el Exterior, CGCDE), an advisory body which represents the interests of Spanish citizens living abroad.[91]
Sweden
Swedish nationals living abroad who have been registered as residents in Sweden are automatically entitled to vote in Riksdag elections and European Parliamentaryelections (for those living in another EU Member State) up to ten years after leaving Sweden. There is no time limit to eligibility, but after the initial 10-year period has elapsed, Swedish expatriates must renew their electoral roll registration by filling out a form every 10 years.[92] They cannot vote in either county or municipal elections. Voting take place either by post or at Swedish embassies.[93] Citizens who have never lived in Sweden are not entitled to vote.[92]
Switzerland
Swiss citizens living abroad may vote, with no expiry date, in elections for the National Council (lower house of parliament) and in federal referendums, provided that they register with the relevant Swiss representation abroad. Their eligibility to vote in elections for the Council of States (upper house of parliament) and in cantonal and municipal elections depends on the law of the canton in which the person was registered before leaving Switzerland.[94][95]
Taiwan
Expatriate suffrage is limited to overseas citizens who have once had household registration in the “Free Area”, and voting is possible only for presidential elections.[96] There is no provision for absentee voting. Voters wanting to exercise this right need to apply to be on the electoral roll before each election; this can be done by post. Then they must physically return to vote at their own polling stations on polling day.[97]
Tunisia
Tunisian expatriates have been granted the right to vote in presidential elections since 1988, and additionally in parliamentary elections since the Tunisian Revolution in 2011. The number of diaspora representatives in the Tunisian parliament is proportional to the size of the diaspora, which makes Tunisia unique.[98]
Turkey
Turkish non-resident citizens have been able to vote in presidential, parliamentary elections and referendums from their country of residences since 2012.[99]
Tuvalu
Tuvaluan citizens residing abroad may vote in Tuvaluan elections if they have been resident in Tuvalu for two of the last three years, or if they own land in the electoral district in which they are registered.[100]
British citizens living abroad can vote in general elections and referendums, with no time limit. The Elections Act 2022 removed the previous rule whereby British citizens residing abroad could vote for up to 15 years after ceasing to live in the UK.[101] This rule was a hotly debated topic among British expatriates who had lived abroad in European Union Member States for more than 15 years at the time of referendum on European Union membership, and were thus barred from voting in it despite it being argued that they were more affected by the result than British people living in the UK.[102][103] The Government intended that registration of overseas electors would be possible from in the autumn of 2023[104] but the required secondary legislation was only laid before Parliament on 23 October 2023.[105] Registration subsequently became possible on 16 January 2024.[106][107][108][109]
United States
US citizens living abroad enjoy full federal voting rights, regardless of how long they have lived abroad. In addition, 38 states, plus the District of Columbia, allow US citizens who have never resided in the US to vote in the state if, at a minimum, it is where their parent or legal guardian last resided. However, some states restrict overseas voters to federal elections only, or allow them to vote only if they have not previously registered or voted in another state.[110] These states include:
Alaska (only federal elections if no intent to return)
Oregon (only if voter intends to reside in Oregon, has a parent, legal guardian, or spouse who is a military or overseas voter under Oregon law and whose last U.S. residence was in Oregon)
As of September 6, 2022, in addition to the five U.S. territories, the following 12 states do not allow U.S. citizens who have never resided in the state to vote there: Alabama, Arkansas, Florida, Idaho, Indiana, Louisiana, Maryland, Mississippi, Missouri, Pennsylvania, Texas, and Utah.
Voting in federal elections for president, vice president, and U.S. Congress has no influence on the voter's tax profile or status. Voting does not trigger tax residency or filing requirements.
Additionally, the Democratic Party, through its overseas arm Democrats Abroad, holds a "global presidential primary" election for U.S. voters abroad. This primary sends its own delegation to the Democratic National Convention. All U.S. citizens who are members of Democrats Abroad are eligible to vote in the primary.
^Wellman, Elizabeth Iams; Allen, Nathan W.; Nyblade, Benjamin (2023). "The Extraterritorial Voting Rights and Restrictions Dataset (1950-2020)". Comparative Political Studies. 56 (6): 910 – via Sage Publications.
^Wellman, Elizabeth Iams; Allen, Nathan W.; Nyblade, Benjamin (2023). "The Extraterritorial Voting Rights and Restrictions Dataset (1950-2020)". Comparative Political Studies. 56 (6): 908 – via Sage Publications.
^ abcEllis, Andrew; Wall, Alan; International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance; Instituto Federal Electoral (Mexico), eds. (2007). Voting from abroad: the International IDEA handbook. Handbook series. Stockholm, Sweden : Mexico City, Mexico: International IDEA ; Federal Electoral Institute of Mexico. ISBN978-91-85391-66-0. OCLC154705040.
^Wellman, Elizabeth Iams; Allen, Nathan W.; Nyblade, Benjamin (2023). "The Extraterritorial Voting Rights and Restrictions Dataset (1950-2020)". Comparative Political Studies. 56 (6): 910 – via Sage Publications.
^ abcLafleur, Jean-Michel, ed. (2013). Transnational politics and the state: the external voting rights of diasporas. Routledge Research in Transnationalism. New York/N.Y: Routledge. ISBN978-0-203-07728-3.
^ abcdeBauböck, Rainer (April 2007). "Stakeholder Citizenship and Transnational Political Participation: A normative Evaluation of External Voting". Fordham Law Review. 75 (5): 2393–2448 – via HeinOnline.
^ abRubio Marin, Ruth (April 2006). "Transnational Politics and the Democratic Nation-State: Normative Challenges of Expatriate Voting and Nationality Retention of Emigrants". New York University Law Review. 81 (1): 117–147 – via HeinOnline.
^Yener-Roderburg, Inci (2020). "Party organizations across borders: Top-down satellites and bottom-up alliances, The case of AKP and HDP in Germany. In Political Parties Abroad (pp. 218-237). Routledge". doi:10.4324/9781003015086-17. S2CID214465283. {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)