All-CAA 1st team Defense – DL Ronnie Cameron, LB Craig Wilkins, P Jonathan Plisco
All-CAA 2nd team Defense – CB Eriq Lewis
All-CAA 3rd team Offense – QB Taylor Heinicke, WR & PR Reid Evans, OL Jeremy Hensley, PK Jarod Brown
All-CAA 3rd team Defense – DL Chris Burnette
Ronnie Cameron – CAA Defensive Player of the Year, seven total All-American Awards (three first team selections, fourth second team selections), 2011 CFPA Elite Defensive tackle Award
Jonathan Plisco – six All-American Awards
Taylor Heinicke – National Freshman Performer of the Year