Division I: At the NCAA Division I level, the Sugar Bears have competed in two NCAA tournaments with a combined record of 0–2 (2016 and 2017). The Sugar Bears have competed in one WNIT with a record of 0–1 (2012). The team has competed in two Women's Basketball Invitational tournament with a record of 3–2 (2011 and 2018).
Division II: The Sugar Bears competed in six NCAA Division II tournaments with a combined record of 8–4 (1996, 2003, 2004, and 2005). The 2003 and 2005 teams competed at the Elite Eight level.
NAIA: As an NAIA member, Central Arkansas competed in two national tournaments (1984 and 1991); two Bi-District Playoff tournaments (1984 and 1985); and one Area V Regional tournament (1983). The overall record for NAIA postseason play was 2–4.[3]