David Rittenhouse Porter (October 31, 1788 – August 6, 1867) was the ninth governor of Pennsylvania.[1] Voted into office during the controversial 1838 Pennsylvania gubernatorial election, which was characterized by intense anti-Masonic and anti-abolitionist rhetoric during and after the contest[2][3] that sparked the post-election Buckshot War,[4][5] he served as the state's chief executive officer from 1839 to 1845.[6]
Porter received a classical education at Norristown Academy.[17] In 1813, he moved to Huntingdon where he studied law with Edward Shippen and eventually purchased an iron works.[18]
Porter also became a member of the Huntingdon Lodge of the Freemasons, rising to the levels of Grand Master of his lodge and Deputy Grand Master of the Masonic district in which his lodge was located.[19][20]
Due to the recession that followed the War of 1812 and his resulting business failure, his life changed markedly. Turning to politics in 1819, he also became a family man, marrying Josephine McDermott in 1820.[21][22]
Career
In 1819, Porter became a member of the Pennsylvania House of Representatives, representing Huntingdon County in 1819 and 1820.[23] He then served in row offices in Huntingdon County and as a member of the Pennsylvania Senate for the 8th district from 1835 to 1838.[24][25][26]
A resident of Huntingdon County in 1838,[27][28] Porter was nominated for governor by the Jacksonian Democrats in order to mend the split between former Governor George Wolf and the Rev. Henry A. P. Muhlenberg, as well as defeat incumbent Governor Joseph Ritner's bid for a second term.[29] His list of supporters included U.S. Senator James Buchanan, who would later become the 15th president of the United States.[30]
A member of the Huntingdon Lodge of the Freemasons, who had risen to the levels of Grand Master of his lodge and Deputy Grand Master of the Masonic district in which his lodge was located, his candidacy received intense scrutiny from his opponents, many of whom were members of the Anti-Masonic Party.[31][32]
After years of Anti-Masonic "witch hunts," however, many prospective voters had tired of the vitriol, giving Porter an opening to effect change. He won the election with a slim 5,500-voter margin. The election result was bitterly contested by Ritner's supporters to the point of violence. Known as the "Buckshot War",[33] Governor Ritner began making plans in Harrisburg to order military intervention to ensure the peaceful transition of government, but members of the legislature worked together to reach consensus and certified the election results before the situation could escalate further, bringing the conflict to an end a few days before Porter's inauguration.[34][35][36] A large crowd attended his inaugural ceremonies on January 15, 1839.[37]
When he assumed office, Porter faced the difficulties of a statewide recession that had begun in 1837 and a state bureaucracy that had spent heavily during the previous years. He pushed for, and then obtained, a tax on persons in professions and the trades similar to the state's income tax, and also secured Pennsylvania's first capital stock share tax while reducing state spending and hiring. Despite these financial changes, his administration was able to continue the state's expansion of its canal and railroad systems, including efforts to connect those systems to the Mississippi River and St. Louis, Missouri, as well as state capitals in Illinois, Indiana and Ohio.[38][39][40]
In 1840, Porter called a special session of the legislature "for consideration of certain financial matters of the Commonwealth."[41]
Porter then easily won re-election in 1841, defeating John Banks, the first Whig gubernatorial candidate to run without having to form a coalition with the Anti-Masonic Party. During his Inaugural Address on January 18, 1842, Porter recalled the state's financial difficulties and presented an overview of his plan for his second term:[42]
"The public debt is substantially the same,—the public burdens only increased to meet obligations then incurred—the public improvements are more productive, and the public revenues essentially augmented. Our banking system, then tottering to its fall, has been examined with searching scrutiny by the public eye—its faults have been detected, its unsoundness exposed, and its dangers guarded against by the dissemination of correct information. The wild and headlong spirit of speculation has been checked. The undue multiplication of the public debt has been restrained, and improvident and wasteful expenditures of the public funds arrested. Experience has painfully demonstrated to the conviction of all, what the sagacious foresight of some apprehended—that nations, like individuals, when they make 'too great haste to get rich' are in danger of bankruptcy and ruin.
We had not yet fortunately, reached the fatal point, from which there was no prospect of escape; but we were verging so near, as to render our rescue alike timely and perilous. Cases of individual hardship no doubt exist; patience, industry and enterprise will effect a cure in most of them; and for those that are remediless, we can but express our sympathy and sorrow.... The Commonwealth, herself, after a short struggle borne with fortitude characteristic of her citizens, and the integrity that they would scorn to tarnish, will overcome all her pecuniary difficulties—will faithfully fulfill her engagements and proudly maintain her honesty and her fame."
By the time Porter had begun that address in 1842, Pennsylvania's legislature had already begun what would become one of the longest sessions in state history, during which it took up the review and debate of a one-mill real estate and personal property tax increase that was pushed by Porter. Lasting two hundred and four calendar days, that session ran from January 4 to July 26. After it was over, Porter signed the new tax increase into effect.[43]
Porter's second term also saw legislative action which abolished the practice of imprisoning people for not paying their debts, as well as the Philadelphia nativist riots of 1844, during which Porter sent in state military troops to quell anti-Catholic violence.[44][45]
During Porter's two terms of executive leadership, Pennsylvania's total debt rose twenty-five percent, but the state was able to pay off the interest on that debt by using revenues that had been generated during his tenure. In addition, he was able to curtail efforts by some General Assembly members to redefine constitutional separations between the executive, judicial and legislative branches of the state's government.[46]
As his second term wound down, Porter decided to retire from politics because Pennsylvania's revised state constitution prohibited him from seeking a third term and because he had developed increasingly difficult relations with both his own party, which opposed his support of protective tariffs, and members of the assembly who had tried to impeach him.[47]
Returning to the private sector, where he resumed his iron manufacturing business in 1844, he oversaw construction of the first anthracite coal furnace for iron in south central Pennsylvania [48][49][50] and operated his own railroad, which linked his furnace to Pennsylvania's larger railroad and canal lines.[51] He then endorsed James Buchanan during his 1856 run for president of the United States.[52][53]
Porter also subsequently helped to promote the extension of the transcontinental railroad through Texas,[54] becoming an associate in the incorporation of the New Mexican Railway Company in 1860.[55]
A vocal opponent of the secession of southern states from the Union, Porter's views were shared by his son, Horace Porter,[56] who distinguished himself in battle during the American Civil War, first as a lieutenant colonel and then as a general. As aide-de-camp to General Grant,[57][58][59] the younger Porter was present to witness the surrender of General Lee, and later wrote a book that has been described as the definitive account of the events at Appomattox Court House.[60]
Illness, death and interment
Falling ill after attending a church meeting in Harrisburg during the winter of 1866-1867, Porter's health continued to decline over a period of several months. He died on August 6, 1867, at the age of 78,[61][62] and was buried in the Harrisburg Cemetery.[63]
^"The Governors of Pennsylvania." Mount Union, Pennsylvania: The Mount Union Times, January 27, 1911, p. 1 (subscription required).
^"The Gathering of the People" and "Democratic Anti-Masonic Meeting." Lancaster, Pennsylvania: Examiner & Herald, June 14, 1838, p. 3 (subscription required).
^Egle, William Henry. "The Buckshot War," in The Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography, Vol. 23, No. 2 (1899), pp. 137-156. Philadelphia, Pennsylvania: University of Pennsylvania Press.
^McCain, George Nox. "A Famous Governor." Philadelphia, Pennsylvania: Evening Public Ledger, June 7, 1921, p. 10 (subscription required).
^Godcharles, "Today's Story in Penna. History: David R. Porter, Iron Master and Governor of Pennsylvania Born October 31, 1788," Intelligencer Journal, October 31, 1924.
^Egle, "The Buckshot War," in The Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography, Vol. 23, No. 2 (1899), pp. 137-156.
^"Remarkable Coincidence," in "Young Men's Convention." Lancaster, Pennsylvania: Examiner & Herald, May 3, 1838, p. 3 (subscription required).
^Hamilton, "City Saw First Inauguration in 1812 at Gay Fete," Harrisburg Telegraph, January 17, 1939.
^Godcharles, "Today's Story in Penna. History: David R. Porter, Iron Master and Governor of Pennsylvania Born October 31, 1788," Intelligencer Journal, October 31, 1924.
^"David Rittenhouse Porter—1839-1845," Semi-Weekly Record, November 23, 1909.
^Hamilton, "City Saw First Inauguration in 1812 at Gay Fete," Harrisburg Telegraph, January 17, 1939.
^Godcharles, "Today's Story in Penna. History: David R. Porter, Iron Master and Governor of Pennsylvania Born October 31, 1788," Intelligencer Journal, October 31, 1924.
^"David Rittenhouse Porter—1839-1845," Semi-Weekly Record, November 23, 1909.
^"Letter from James Buchanan to Reuel William" (U.S. Senator Buchanan discusses David Porter and the 1838 gubernatorial election in Pennsylvania). Carlisle, Pennsylvania: Dickinson College, Archives & Special Collections, retrieved online December 30, 2022.
^Egle, "The Buckshot War," in The Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography, 1899.
^"Remarkable Coincidence," in "Young Men's Convention," Examiner & Herald, May 3, 1838.
^Egle, "The Buckshot War," in The Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography, 1899.
^"David Rittenhouse Porter—1839-1845," Semi-Weekly Record, November 23, 1909.
^Godcharles, "Today's Story in Penna. History: David R. Porter, Iron Master and Governor of Pennsylvania Born October 31, 1788," Intelligencer Journal, October 31, 1924.
^Godcharles, "Today's Story in Penna. History: David R. Porter, Iron Master and Governor of Pennsylvania Born October 31, 1788," Intelligencer Journal, October 31, 1924.
^Godcharles, "Today's Story in Penna. History: David R. Porter, Iron Master and Governor of Pennsylvania Born October 31, 1788," Intelligencer Journal, October 31, 1924.
^Godcharles, "Today's Story in Penna. History: David R. Porter, Iron Master and Governor of Pennsylvania Born October 31, 1788," Intelligencer Journal, October 31, 1924.
^Hamilton, "City Saw First Inauguration in 1812 at Gay Fete," Harrisburg Telegraph, January 17, 1939.
^Godcharles, "Today's Story in Penna. History: David R. Porter, Iron Master and Governor of Pennsylvania Born October 31, 1788," Intelligencer Journal, October 31, 1924.
^Hamilton, "City Saw First Inauguration in 1812 at Gay Fete," Harrisburg Telegraph, January 17, 1939.
^Godcharles, "Today's Story in Penna. History: David R. Porter, Iron Master and Governor of Pennsylvania Born October 31, 1788," Intelligencer Journal, October 31, 1924.
^"President Unveiled It." Baltimore, Maryland: The Baltimore Sun, May 17, 1897, p. 7 (subscription required).