On May 20, 1989, Hying was ordained a priest for the Archdiocese of Milwaukee at the Cathedral of St. John the Evangelist in Milwaukee by Archbishop Rembert Weakland.[1]After his ordination, the archdiocese assigned Hying as associate pastor of St. Anthony Parish in Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin, where he served for the next five years.[2]
In 1994, Hying traveled to the Dominican Republic to serve as a missionary at the Sacred Family Parish in Sabana Yegua. After returning to Wisconsin in 1998, the archdiocese appointed him as temporary administrator of St. Peter Parish in East Troy, Wisconsin. Later that year, he was moved to St. Anthony Parish in Milwaukee, where he worked as associate pastor for one year.[2]
Hying was appointed pastor in 1999 of Our Lady of Good Hope Parish in Milwaukee, remaining there until 2005. He then became the dean of formation at Saint Francis de Sales Seminary from 2005 until 2007, when was named rector. In 2006, while serving at the seminary, Hying was placed as a temporary administrator at St. Augustine Parish in Milwaukee.[3]
On November 24, 2014, Pope Francis appointed Hying as the fourth bishop of Gary, replacing the retiring Bishop Dale Joseph Melczek.[6][7] Hying's installation in Gary took place on January 6, 2015. While he was bishop of Gary, Hying oversaw that diocese's first synod in 2017.
Bishop of Madison
On April 25, 2019, Pope Francis named Hying as bishop of Madison to replace the late Bishop Robert Morlino.[8][9] Hying was installed on June 25, 2019.[10]
In March 2020, Hying announced that investigators had found two sexual abuse allegations against Reverend Patrick Doherty, a retired diocesan priest, to be credible. Hying had already placed restrictions on Doherty.[11][12]
In June 2020, Hying criticized the destruction by protesters of religious statues during protests after the murder of George Floyd by a policeman. He also stated that some statues might merit removal and storage. Hying also condemned civil rights activist Shaun King for calling for the destruction images of Jesus as a white man.[13]