Hay also spent time in the American Hockey League, ECHL, and the Central Hockey League. During his time with the Pensacola Ice Pilots of the ECHL, Hay was named the In Glas Co ECHL Player of the Week for the week of December 13–19, 2004.[1]
Hay had initially signed with the Fresno Falcons of the ECHL in July 2007 as a training camp invite[2] but was eventually released by the team in October.[3] Upon being released by the Falcons, Hay had agreed to play with the Nottingham Panthers of the EIHL. Two days after agreeing to terms, Hay announced that he "would not be in a position to pass a medical on arrival and has been forced to retire from the sport".[4] Despite this, Hay then played with the Bentley Generals of the Chinook Hockey League for the 2007-08 hockey season.[5]
He agreed to play with the Corner Brook Royals during the 2008-09 season. Despite promising to "at least play all home games", Hay was a no-show to several team functions a week prior to the Royals' first home game, and decided to play with the then-Swedish Division 1 team Örebro HK.[3]
Hay signed with the Arizona Sundogs of the Central Hockey League on January 28, 2009.[6]
Hay most recently played with HC Alleghe of Serie A, a top-tier ice hockey league in Italy.[7]
Hay currently resides in London, Ontario, coaching London Cobras U9,[8] while offering Hockey Development Camps on weekends and PA Days for hockey players born 2009 and younger.[9] Hay previously resided in Calgary, Alberta and ran the DH One Speed Athletics Hockey School and Bootcamps.[5]