Plaza Accord

Plaza Accord
	The 1985 "Plaza Accord" is named after New York City's Plaza Hotel, which was the location of a meeting of finance ministers who reached an agreement about managing the fluctuating value of the US dollar. From left are Gerhard Stoltenberg of West Germany, Pierre Bérégovoy of France, James A. Baker III of the United States, Nigel Lawson of Britain, and Noboru Takeshita of Japan.
Signed	September 22, 1985
Signatories	Pierre Bérégovoy; Gerhard Stoltenberg; Noboru Takeshita; Nigel Lawson; James Baker;
Parties	France; West Germany; Japan; United Kingdom; United States;
Language	English

The Plaza Accord was a joint agreement signed on September 22, 1985, at the Plaza Hotel in New York City, between France, West Germany, Japan, the United Kingdom, and the United States, to depreciate the U.S. dollar in relation to the French franc, the German Deutsche Mark, the Japanese yen and the British pound sterling by intervening in currency markets. The U.S. dollar depreciated significantly from the time of the agreement until it was replaced by the Louvre Accord in 1987.^[1]^[2]^[3] Some commentators believe the Plaza Accord contributed to the Japanese asset price bubble of the late 1980s.^[4]^[5]^[6]

Background

The tight monetary policy of Federal Reserve's Chairman Paul Volcker and the expansionary fiscal policy of President Ronald Reagan's first term in 1981–84 pushed up long-term interest rates and attracted capital inflow, appreciating the dollar.^[7] The French government was strongly in favor of currency intervention to reduce it, but US administration officials, such as Treasury Secretary Donald Regan and Under Secretary for Monetary Affairs, Beryl Sprinkel, opposed such plans, considering the strong dollar a vote of confidence in the US economy and supporting the concept of free market above all else.^[7] At the 1982 G7 Versailles Summit, the US agreed to a request by the other members to a study of the effectiveness of foreign currency intervention, which resulted in the Jurgensen Report at the 1983 G7 Williamsburg Summit, but it was not as supportive of intervention as the other leaders had hoped. As the dollar's appreciation kept rising and the trade deficit grew even more, the second Reagan administration viewed currency intervention in a different light. In January 1985, James Baker became the new Treasury Secretary and Baker's aide Richard Darman became Deputy Secretary of the Treasury. David Mulford joined as the new Assistant Secretary for International Affairs.^[7]

From 1980 to 1985, the dollar had appreciated by about 50% against the Japanese yen, Deutsche Mark, French franc, and British pound, the currencies of the next four biggest economies at the time.^[8] In March 1985, just before the G7, the dollar reached its highest valuation ever against the British pound, a valuation which would remain untopped for over 30 years.^[9] This caused considerable difficulties for the American industry, but at first, their lobbying was largely ignored by the government. The financial sector was able to profit from the rising dollar, and a depreciation would have run counter to the Reagan administration's plans for bringing down inflation. A broad alliance of manufacturers, service providers, and farmers responded by running an increasingly high-profile campaign asking for protection against foreign competition. Major players included grain exporters, the U.S. automotive industry, heavy American manufacturers like Caterpillar Inc., as well as high-tech companies including IBM and Motorola. By 1985, their campaign had acquired sufficient traction for Congress to begin considering passing protectionist laws. The negative prospect of trade restrictions spurred the White House to begin the negotiations that led to the Plaza Accord.^[10]^[11]

The devaluation was justified to reduce the U.S. current account deficit, which had reached 3.5% of the GDP, and to help the U.S. economy to emerge from a serious recession that began in the early 1980s. The U.S. Federal Reserve System under Paul Volcker had halted the stagflation crisis of the 1970s by raising interest rates. The increased interest rate sufficiently controlled domestic monetary policy and staved off inflation. By the mid-1970s, Nixon successfully convinced several OPEC countries to trade oil only in USD, and the US would, in return, give them regional military support. This sudden infusion of international demand for dollars gave the USD the infusion it needed in the 1970s.^[12] However, a strong dollar is a double edged sword, inducing the Triffin dilemma which, on the one hand, gave more spending power to domestic consumers, companies, and to the US government, and on the other hand, hampered US exports until the value of the dollar re-equilibrated. The U.S. automobile industry was unable to recover.

Meeting at the Plaza Hotel

At the 17 January 1985 G5 meeting attended by James Baker, a small amount of currency intervention to depreciate the dollar was agreed upon and subsequently took place. US intervention was small in those months, but the German authorities intervened heavily to sell dollars in foreign exchange markets in February and March. In April at an OECD meeting, the US announced their potential interest in a meeting between the major industrial countries on the subject of international monetary reform, and preparations for the Plaza meeting began, with preparatory meetings by G5 deputies in July and August. On 22 September 1985, the finance ministers and central bank governors of the United States, France, Germany, Japan and Great Britain met at the Plaza Hotel in New York City and came to an agreement on the announcement that "some further orderly appreciation of the non-dollar currencies is desirable" and they "stand ready to cooperate more closely to encourage this when to do so would be helpful". The following Monday, when the meeting was made public, the dollar fell 4 percent in comparison to the other currencies.^[7]

Effects

Trade deficit

While for the first two years, the US deficit only worsened, it then began to turn around as the elasticities had risen enough that the quantity effects began to outweigh the valuation effect.^[7] The devaluation made U.S. exports cheaper to purchase for its trading partners, which in turn allegedly meant that other countries would buy more American-made goods and services. The Plaza Accord failed to help reduce the U.S.–Japan trade deficit, but it did reduce the U.S. deficit with other countries by making U.S. exports more competitive.^[4]^{[better source needed]} And thus, the US Congress refrained from enacting protectionist trade barriers.^[7]

Objective failure

Joseph E. Gagnon describes the Plaza's result being more due to the message that was sent to the financial markets about policy intentions and the implied threat of further dollar sales than actual policies. Intervention was far more pronounced in the opposite direction following the 1987 Louvre Accord, when the dollar's depreciation was decided to be halted.^[13]

The Plaza Accord was successful in reducing the U.S. trade deficit with Western European nations, but largely failed to fulfill its primary objective of alleviating the trade deficit with Japan. This deficit was due to structural conditions that were insensitive to monetary policy, specifically trade conditions. The manufactured goods of the United States became more competitive in the exports market, though were still largely unable to succeed in the Japanese domestic market due to Japan's structural restrictions on imports. The Louvre Accord was signed in 1987 to halt the continuing decline of the U.S. dollar.

Following the subsequent 1987 Louvre Accord, there were few other interventions in the dollar's exchange rate such as by the first Clinton Administration in 1992–95. However, since then, currency interventions have been few among the G7. The European Central Bank supported in 2000 then over-depreciated euro. The Bank of Japan intervened for the last time in 2011, with the cooperation of the US and others to dampen strong appreciation of the yen after the 2011 Tōhoku earthquake and tsunami. In 2013, the G7 members agreed to refrain from foreign exchange intervention. Since then, the US administration has demanded stronger international policies against currency manipulation (to be differentiated from monetary stimulus).^[7]

The signing of the Plaza Accord was significant in that it reflected Japan's emergence as a real player in managing the international monetary system.^{[citation needed]} However, the rising yen may also have contributed to recessionary pressures for Japan's economy, to which the Japanese government reacted with massive expansionary monetary and fiscal policies. That stimulus in combination with other policies led to the Japanese asset price bubble of the late 1980s.^[4] Because of this, some commentators blame the Plaza Accord for the bubble, which, when burst, led into a protracted period of deflation and low growth in Japan known as the Lost Decade, which has effects still heavily felt in modern Japan.^[14]^[15] Jeffrey Frankel disagrees on the timing, pointing out that between the 1985–86 years of appreciation of the yen and the 1990s recession, came the bubble years of 1987–89 when the exchange rate no longer pushed the yen up.^[7] The rising Deutsche Mark also did not lead to an economic bubble or a recession in Germany.^[6]^[5] Economist Richard Werner says that external pressures such as the accord and the policy of Ministry of Finance to reduce the official discount rate are insufficient in explaining the actions taken by the Bank of Japan that led to the bubble.^[16]

References

^ "Economy: Announcement of [G5] Finance Ministers & Central Bank Governors (the Plaza Agreement)". margaretthatcher.org. Margaret Thatcher Foundation. Archived from the original on December 3, 2018. Retrieved December 3, 2018.
^ "Announcement the Ministers of Finance and Central Bank Governors of France, Germany, Japan, the United Kingdom, and the United States (Plaza Accord)". g8.utoronto.ca. University of Toronto. Archived from the original on December 3, 2018. Retrieved December 3, 2018.
^ Funabashi, Yōichi (1989). Managing the Dollar: From the Plaza to the Louvre (2nd ed.). Institute for International Economics. pp. 261–271. ISBN 978-0-88132-097-8.
^ ^a ^b ^c Hargrave, Marshall (August 22, 2019). "Plaza Accord". Investopedia. Retrieved April 8, 2021.
^ ^a ^b Funabashi, Yoichi (September 11, 2018). "A U.S.-China 'Plaza Accord'?". The Japan Times. Retrieved May 29, 2021.
^ ^a ^b Shen, Simon. "Did the Plaza Accord 'conspiracy' doom Japan, and is China next?". EJ Insight. Hong Kong Economic Journal. Retrieved May 29, 2021.
^ ^a ^b ^c ^d ^e ^f ^g ^h Frankel, Jeffrey. "The Plaza Accord, 30 Years Later" (PDF). National Bureau of Economic Research (No. w21813). Retrieved May 29, 2021.
^ Brook, Anne-Marie; Sédillot, Franck; Ollivaud, Patrice (May 18, 2004). "Channels for Narrowing the US Current Account Deficit and Implications for Other Economies". OECD Economics Department Working Papers (390). Paris: OECD Publishing: 8, figure 3. doi:10.1787/263550547141.
^ Wilkes, Tommy; Chatterjee, Saikat (September 3, 2019). "Plotting sterling's latest lurch - just how low did it go?". Reuters. Archived from the original on September 3, 2019. Retrieved April 8, 2021. The all-time low was $1.0545 touched in March 1985, just before G7 powers acted to rein in the superdollar of the Reagan era in the so-called "Plaza Accord".
^ Hiscox, Michael J. (2005). "The Domestic Sources of Foreign Economic Policies". In Ravenhill, John (ed.). Global Political Economy (1st ed.). Oxford; New York: Oxford University Press. p. 65. ISBN 0-19-926584-4. OCLC 60383498.
^ Destler, I. M.; Henning, C. Randall (1993). Dollar Politics: Exchange Rate Policymaking in the United States. Institute for International Economics. pp. 105–130. ISBN 978-0-88132-079-4.
^ Tun, Zaw Thiha (April 21, 2020). "How Petrodollars Affect the U.S. Dollar". Investopedia. Retrieved April 8, 2021.
^ Gagnon, Joseph E. (2016). "Foreign Exchange Intervention since the Plaza Accord". In Bergsten, C. Fred; Green, Russell A. (eds.). International Monetary Cooperation: Lessons from the Plaza Accord after Thirty Years.
^ "China seeks to learn from mistakes of 1985 Plaza Accord". The Japan Times. September 9, 2006. Retrieved September 27, 2011.
^ Archived at Ghostarchive and the Wayback Machine: Fukuda, Yasuo (May 14, 2019). "China raises tariffs in response to U.S. measures / Lessons on Japan-U.S. trade deal in the 1980s". World Insight with Tian Wei (Interview). Interviewed by Tian Wei. CGTN. Event occurs at 28:23–32:29. Retrieved April 8, 2021 – via YouTube.
^ Werner, Richard A. (2002). "Monetary Policy Implementation in Japan: What They Say versus What They Do". Asian Economic Journal. 16 (2): 111–151. doi:10.1111/1467-8381.00145.