On 19 November 2017, wrestling under her real name, lost to Nina Samuels for London Lucha League.[1] On 3 February, at the DWA Wrestling Legendshow 2019 event, Gibbs won the vacant DWA Ladies Championship, her first title in her career, after defeating ODB. On 2 January 2019, Gibbs made her debut for World Wonder Ring Stardom, teaming up with Mari Apache, losing to J.A.N. (Jungle Kyona and Ruaka).[2] On 3 January, Gibbs competed again with Mary Apache and Natsumi, winning against Hanan, Hina and Rina. On 5 January, Gibbs wrestled Jamie Hayter to a 10-minute time limit draw.[3] On 19 January, Gibbs made her last appearance in Stardom, teaming with Bobbi Tyler and Hana Kimura, and defeated STARS (Mayu Iwatani, Starlight Kid and Tam Nakano).[4]
In mid-2019, it was reported that Gibbs was close to signing a contract with All Elite Wrestling (AEW).[5] On 25 May, during the Double or Nothing pre-show, Gibbs' promo was shown, confirming her signing by the promotion.[6] On 31 August at All Out, she made her debut during the Women's Casino Battle Royale, being one of three women to eliminate Awesome Kong, before being eliminated by rival Bea Priestley.[7] On the 5 November episode of AEW Dark, Gibbs picked up her first victory by pinning Big Swole, in a tag team match with Allie against Swole and Mercedes Martinez.[8] Gibbs was released from AEW on 13 August 2020.[9]
On 28 April 2021, Sadie announced her retirement from professional wrestling via an Instagram post to focus on her fitness career.[10][11]
In 2024, Gibbs came out of retirement and has continued her professional wrestling career, most notably wrestling in the Japanese promotion Pro Wrestling Noah.[12]
