In February 2016, after leaving the Nike Academy, Clare signed a contract with Sheffield Wednesday until 2017.[4] He scored his first goal for Wednesday in a 4–2 defeat to Aston Villa on 24 February 2018.[5]
Bury (loan)
In March 2016 he signed for Bury on loan,[6] making his professional debut on 5 March against Bradford City.
Accrington Stanley (loan)
On 20 January 2017 he signed a loan until the end of the season with Accrington Stanley. Accrington manager John Coleman stated he was happy to add another attacking option to the squad with the signing of Clare.[7] His first appearance for Accrington was part of a 1–1 draw against Carlisle United.[8]
Gillingham (loan)
On 31 August 2017, he signed for Gillingham on loan until 3 January.[9] He scored his first league goal for the club in his second appearance, against AFC Wimbledon on 12 September 2017.[10]
In January 2018 Clare was recalled from his loan spell back to Sheffield Wednesday making his first senior debut in a 0–0 draw against city rivalsSheffield United.[11]
On 6 August 2020, Clare signed for League One club Oxford United, for an undisclosed fee, on a three-year deal.[13]
Burton Albion (loan)
On 12 January 2021, Clare joined League One side Burton Albion on loan for the remainder of the 2020–21 season.[14] He scored his first goal for Burton in a 2–1 defeat to Shrewsbury Town on 23 March 2021.[15]