Thomas L. Thompson (born January 7, 1939, in Detroit, Michigan) is an American-born Danish biblical scholar and theologian. He was professor of theology at the University of Copenhagen from 1993 to 2009. He currently lives in Denmark.
Thompson is a part of the minimalist movement known as the Copenhagen School, a group of scholars who hold that the Bible cannot be used as a source to determine the history of ancient Israel, and that "Israel" itself is a problematic concept.[1]
Biography
Thompson was raised as a Catholic and obtained a Bachelor of Arts from Duquesne University, in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, United States, in 1962. After a year in Oxford, he moved to Tübingen, where he studied for 12 years with Kurt Galling and Herbert Haag.[2] In the meantime, he was an instructor in theology at Dayton University (1964–65) and assistant professor in Old Testament studies at the University of Detroit (1967–69). He then studied Catholic theology at the University of Tübingen; his dissertation, "The Historicity of the Patriarchal Narratives: The Quest for the Historical Abraham", was completed in 1971, but rejected by the Catholic faculty (one of his examiners was Joseph Ratzinger, then Tübingen's Professor of Systematic Theology and later Pope Benedict XVI). Thompson then considered submitting his dissertation to the Protestant faculty, but left Tübingen in 1975 without a degree. The rejected dissertation was published in 1974 by De Gruyter Press.[3] The work, together with John Van Seters' Abraham in History and Tradition, became one of the pioneer works of biblical minimalism.[2]
The controversy around his dissertation prevented him from obtaining a position at a North American university.[6] He continued as a private scholar while working as a high-school teacher, janitor, and house painter until he was awarded a guest professorship at the École Biblique in Jerusalem in 1984. This appointment proved controversial among Israelis, who, according to Thompson, objected to his earlier study casting doubt on the historicity of the Jewish origin narratives.[clarification needed] He then worked on a project on Palestinian place names for UNESCO, criticizing Israeli authorities for de-Arabicizing Palestinian place names. Accusations of antisemitism led to the project being closed.[4]
Thompson was named a National Endowment for the Humanities fellow in 1988. He taught as visiting associate professor at Lawrence University (1988–89) and as associate professor at Marquette University (1989–1993), but did not receive tenure. In 1990, he met Danish theologian Niels Peter Lemche at a conference, and in 1993, joined the faculty of the department of theology at the University of Copenhagen as professor in Old Testament exegesis. He retired and was granted emeritus status in 2009.
Thompson is general editor for the series Copenhagen International Seminar, associate editor of the Scandinavian Journal of the Old Testament, and serves on the editorial boards of the journals Holy Land Studies and Dansk Teologisk Tidsskrift.[7]
Old Testament writings
The focus of Thompson's writing has been the interface between the Bible (specifically the Old Testament) and archaeology. His The Historicity of the Patriarchal Narratives (1974) was a critique of the then-dominant view that biblical archaeology had demonstrated the historicity of figures such as Abraham and other Biblical patriarchs.[8] His The Early History of the Israelite People From the Written and Archaeological Sources (1993) set out his argument that the biblical history was not reliable, and concludes: "The linguistic and literary reality of the biblical tradition is folkloristic in essence. The concept of a benei Israel ... is a reflection of no sociopolitical entity of the historical state of Israel of the Assyrian period...."[8] In The Bible in History: How Writers Create a Past (U.S. title: The Mythic Past: Biblical Archaeology and the Myth of Israel), he argued that the Old Testament was entirely, or almost entirely, a product of the period between the fifth and second centuries BC.[9]
Thompson's arguments were criticized by many biblical scholars, prominent among them William G. Dever in his book What Did the Biblical Writers Know and When Did They Know It?, which has been described as "a very polemic and partly vehement attack not least against Professor Thomas L. Thompson".[10] Thompson himself reviewed Dever's book and provided his own responses to Dever's critiques. The fact that Thompson, as a target of many of the critiques advanced in the book would have chosen to review it, was criticized by H. Hagelia.[10]
New Testament writings
Thompson presented a criticism of the historicity of the New Testament in his 2005 book, The Messiah Myth: The Near Eastern Roots of Jesus and David,[11][12] He argues that the biblical accounts of both King David and Jesus of Nazareth are mythical in nature and based on Mesopotamian, Egyptian, Babylonian, and Greek and Roman literature. For example, he argues that the resurrection of Jesus is taken directly from the myths about Dionysus, which he described as a "dying and rising god". Thompson did not draw a final conclusion on the historicity or ahistoricity of Jesus. He was a fellow of the short-lived Jesus Project from 2008 to 2009.[13]
The Messiah Myth was criticized by New Testament scholars such as Bart Ehrman, who in 2012 published a criticism of Jesus ahistoricity theory proponents,[14]Did Jesus Exist? The Historical Argument for Jesus of Nazareth,[15] in which he stated that "A different sort of support for a mythicist position comes in the work of Thomas L. Thompson," and critiqued Thompson's arguments and criticized Thompson, as an Old Testament scholar, for lacking the sufficient background in New Testament studies to provide a useful analysis of the text.[16] In 2012, Thompson responded with the online article, Is This Not the Carpenter’s Son? A Response to Bart Ehrman, in which he rejects Ehrman's characterization of his views, stating that Erhman "has attributed to my book arguments and principles which I had never presented, certainly not that Jesus had never existed."[17] Ehrman's views were defended by New Testament scholar Maurice Casey, who dismissed Thompson as "an incompetent scholar".[18]
Thompson and Thomas Verenna coedited the 2012 book Is This Not the Carpenter?: The Question of the Historicity of the Figure of Jesus.[19][20] The introduction defined the purpose of the collected essays: "Neither establishing the historicity of an historical Jesus nor possessing an adequate warrant for dismissing it, our purpose is to clarify our engagement with critical historical and exegetical methods."[21] Thompson's views about the New Testament are rejected by mainstream scholarship.[22][23]
Criticism
Thompson's minimalist positions have generated a considerable controversy in the academic field and have received strong criticism from a number of scholars. Archaeologist and Old Testament scholar William G. Dever (University of Arizona, later Lycoming College) has repeatedly expressed harsh criticism of Thompson's views in his works, even devoting an entire book in challenging them (What Did the Biblical Writers Know and When Did They Know It?), in which he defended the historical value of the Bible from the Book of Judges and onwards: according to Dever, Thompson's theorems are dangerous, because it tends to eliminate altogether any study of ancient Israel prior to the Persian period.[24]
Even harsher criticism has come from evangelical scholars, such as Kenneth Kitchen (University of Liverpool), whose book On the Reliability of the Old Testament consistently defends the historicity of the Tanakh.[25] Taking a different approach, A Biblical History of Israel, by Iain Provan, V. Philips Long, and Tremper Longman III (Regent College), argued that criterion of distrust set by the minimalists (the Bible should be regarded as unreliable unless directly confirmed by external sources) was unreasonable, and that it should be regarded as reliable unless directly falsified. Avi Hurvitz (Hebrew University of Jerusalem) compared biblical Hebrew with the Hebrew from ancient inscriptions and found it consistent with the period before the Persian period, thus questioning the key minimalist contention that the biblical books were written several centuries after the events they describe.[26]Takamitsu Muraoka (Leiden University) also argues against the hypothesis that the entire Hebrew Bible was composed in the Persian period, associated with some minimalists like Davies, countering that there are specifically late Biblical Hebrew features, like some rare plene spellings, that are contained in books dated to the Persian era by minimalists as well, but unusual or absent elsewhere.[27]
Italian scholar Mario Liverani (Sapienza University of Rome) has also been critical of Thompson's views: in his book Israel's History and the History of Israel, Liverani accepts that the biblical sources are from the Persian period, but believes that the minimalists have not truly understood that context nor recognised the importance of the ancient sources used by the authors.[28]
Thompson's works on the New Testament have been met with even stronger criticism: in his book Did Jesus Exist?, Bart D. Ehrman (University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill) critiqued Thompson's arguments and criticized Thompson, as an Old Testament scholar, for lacking the sufficient background in New Testament studies to provide a useful analysis of the text.[29] Similar criticism came from Maurice Casey (University of Nottingham), who went even so far as to call Thompson "an incompetent" in the field of New Testament studies.[30][31] Dever dismissed Thompson's views about Jesus as "an ongoing campaign that isn't mainstream anywhere in biblical studies".[23]
Thompson, Thomas L.; Maniragaba Balibutsa; Margaret M. Clarkson (1975). The Settlement of Sinai and the Negev in the Bronze Age. Reichert. ISBN978-3-920153-44-5.
Thompson, Thomas L. (1979). The settlement of Palestine in the Bronze Age. Reichert. ISBN978-3-88226-069-4.
Thompson, Thomas L. (1987). The Origin Tradition of Ancient Israel. JSOT Press. ISBN978-1-85075-083-3.
Thompson, Thomas L.; Francolino J. Gonçalves; Jean-Marie van Cangh (1988). Toponymie palestinienne: plaine de St Jean d'Acre et corridor de Jérusalem. Université catholique de Louvain, Institut orientaliste.
Cryser, Frederick H.; Thomas L. Thompson, eds. (1998). Qumran Between the Old and New Testament. Continuum International Publishing Group. ISBN978-0-567-18135-0.
Thompson, Thomas L., ed. (2003). Jerusalem in ancient history and tradition. T & T Clark International. ISBN978-0-8264-6664-8.
(With Z. Mouna et alii), What is New in Biblical Archaeology (in Arabic: Cadmus: Damascus, 2004)
Tronier, Henrik; Thomas L. Thompson, eds. (2004). Frelsens biografisering. Museum Tusculanum Press. ISBN978-87-635-0214-6.
Mogens, Müller; Thomas L. Thompson, eds. (2005). Historie og konstruktion: festskrift til Nils Peter Lemche i anledning af 60 års fødselsdagen den 6. september 2005. Museum Tusculanum Press. ISBN978-87-635-0377-8.
Thompson, Thomas L. (2007). The Messiah Myth: The Near Eastern Roots of Jesus and David. Basic Books. ISBN978-0-7867-3911-0.
Thompson, Thomas L.; Thomas S. Verenna, eds. (2012). 'Is This Not the Carpenter?': The Question of the Historicity of the Figure of Jesus. Isd. ISBN978-1-84553-986-3.
Thompson, Thomas L. (2013). Biblical Narrative and Palestine's History: Changing Perspectives 2. Equinox Publishing Limited. ISBN978-1-908049-95-7.
References
^Maurice CaseyJesus: Evidence and Argument or Mythicist Myths? T&T Clark 2014 THOMAS L. THOMPSON p.24
^ abPhilip R Davies.'Introduction' to Thomas L. Thompson, Biblical Narrative and Palestine's History: Changing Perspectives 2, Routledge 2014 p.1.
^ abMarc Brettler. "The Copenhagen School: The Historiographical Issues The Copenhagen School: The Historiographical Issues", AJS Review, Vol. 27, No. 1 (April 2003), p. 1-21
^ abH. Hagelia. (2002). "Review or response? A critical evaluation of Thomas L. Thompson's review of William G. Dever." Scandinavian Journal of the Old Testament, 16(2), 314-318.
^ abDever, William G. (2017-11-03). Beyond the Texts: An Archaeological Portrait of Ancient Israel and Judah. SBL Press. p. 55. ISBN978-0-88414-217-1. Lately, even the New Testament narratives and the historicity of Jesus of Nazareth have been called into question by Hjelm, Thompson and others, again at the Copenhagen International Symposium and other publications. None of this ongoing campaign is mainstream in biblical studies anywhere [...]
Commune and town in Tizi Ouzou, AlgeriaAghribsCommune and townView of AghribsAghribs in Azzefoun DistrictAghribsAghribs shown in AlgeriaCoordinates: 36°48′08″N 4°19′22″E / 36.80222°N 4.32278°E / 36.80222; 4.32278Country AlgeriaProvinceTizi OuzouPopulation (2008) • Total12,474Time zoneUTC+1 (CET) Aghrib or Aghribs (Arabic: أغريب; Berber languages: ⴰⵖⵔⵉⴱ) is a village and commune in the province of Tizi Ouzou in northern Alge…
Данн-е-Катр-ВанDanne-et-Quatre-Vents Країна Франція Регіон Гранд-Ест Департамент Мозель Округ Саррбур-Шато-Сален Кантон Фальсбур Код INSEE 57168 Поштові індекси 57370 Координати 48°46′02″ пн. ш. 7°17′43″ сх. д.H G O Висота 205 - 379 м.н.р.м. Площа 7,2 км² Населення 676 (01-2020[1]) Г
Bharata (Sanskerta: भरट; Bharaṭa) adalah tokoh protagonis dari wiracarita Ramayana. Ia adalah putera prabu Dasarata dengan permaisuri Kekayi, dan merupakan adik Rama. Konon Bharata adalah raja dari golongan Suryawangsa yang sangat baik dan bijaksana setelah Rama. Menurut pandangan Hindu, Bharata lahir dari aspek Chakra Sudarshana yang terletak di tangan kanan Dewa Wisnu. Kelahiran dan keluarga Bharata merupakan putera dari Kekayi, istri ketiga Raja Dasarata dari Ayodhya. Ia memiliki tiga…
Teatro Karl Marx Fachada del teatro, con la firma de Carlos Marx como nombre.LocalizaciónPaís CubaLocalidad La HabanaDirección Avenida 1.ª, entre 8 y 10, Miramar, Playa, La HabanaCoordenadas 23°07′46″N 82°25′11″O / 23.1294, -82.4197Información generalApertura ca. 1949Cierre ca. 1970Reapertura 1975CaracterísticasAforo 5500 espectadores[editar datos en Wikidata] El Teatro Karl Marx es un teatro en La Habana, Cuba,[1] (Originalmente llamado 'Te…
City in Texas, United StatesFort Stockton, TexasCityHistorical places in Fort StocktonNickname(s): Stockton; StakitasMotto: The Heart of Pecos CountyLocation of Fort Stockton, TexasCoordinates: 30°53′29″N 102°53′6″W / 30.89139°N 102.88500°W / 30.89139; -102.88500[1]CountryUnited StatesStateTexasCountyPecosGovernment • MayorPaul CasiasArea[2] • Total5.55 sq mi (14.37 km2) • Land5.55…
Wapen van de familie de Beauffort uit Artesië Het Kasteel de Beauffort in Linden Kasteel van Loyers Het kasteel van Bouchout in Meise De Beauffort is een adellijke Belgische familie, afkomstig uit Artesië, die niet te verwarren is met de familie Beaufort Spontin of met andere families de Beauffort in Frankrijk. Geschiedenis Artesië Heel wat de Beaufforts zijn in de kronieken te noteren vanaf de twaalfde eeuw. Verschillende onder hen trokken mee op kruistochten, onder meer in 1248 onder de lei…
Artikel ini sebatang kara, artinya tidak ada artikel lain yang memiliki pranala balik ke halaman ini.Bantulah menambah pranala ke artikel ini dari artikel yang berhubungan atau coba peralatan pencari pranala.Tag ini diberikan pada Maret 2016. Tong Tji adalah salah satu perusahaan teh ternama di Indonesia. Berdiri sejak tahun 1938 di Tegal, Jawa Tengah oleh alm. Tan See Giam. Tong Tji merupakan nama Brand sedangkan nama perusahaannya adalah Perusahaan Teh Wangi Dua Burung. Sejak 2017, Perusahaan …
У Вікіпедії є статті про інші значення цього терміна: Чернігів (значення). U310 «Чернігів» Історія →Радянський Союз→Росія Назва: «Зенітник» (рос. «Зенитчик»)Власник: ВМФ СРСР→ВМФ РосіїБудівник: Середньоневський СБЗ, Ленінград СРСРБудівельний номер: 928Закладений: 1974 рік
هذا اسمٌ كوريّ؛ وبذلك فإن يانغ هو اسم العائلة نيكي يانغ معلومات شخصية اسم الولادة هيون جيونغ يانغ الميلاد 8 يونيو 1985 (38 سنة)[1] سول، كوريا الجنوبية مواطنة كوريا الجنوبية أسماء أخرى نيكي هيون يانغ الحياة العملية المدرسة الأم معهد كاليفورنيا للفنون المهنة رسامة رس…
Empty burial chamberWashington's Tomb displaying Lincoln Catafalque, 2007 Washington's Tomb is an empty burial chamber two stories directly below the Rotunda of the United States Capitol building in Washington, DC. It was included in the original design of the building by William Thornton and intended to entomb the body of George Washington, the first President of the United States. The original design of the rotunda, and the Crypt beneath it, included a central glass floor allowing the public t…
Operations since the cold war This list is incomplete; you can help by adding missing items. (April 2020) Although the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) existed as an alliance and conducted joint military exercises throughout the Cold War period, it engaged in no military operations during this time. All of its military operations occurred in the post-Cold War era. The first of these was in Bosnia, where NATO engaged to an increasing extent. This engagement culminated in NATO's 1995 air …
2009 greatest hits album by Black Label SocietySkullageGreatest hits album by Black Label SocietyReleasedApril 21, 2009Recorded1994–2006GenreHeavy metalLabelArmoury, Eagle RockBlack Label Society chronology Shot to Hell(2006) Skullage(2009) Order of the Black(2010) Professional ratingsReview scoresSourceRatingAllMusic[1]Blabbermouth.net5/10[2]Brave Words & Bloody Knuckles7/10[3]Stormbringer3/5[4]The Hollywood Reporter(favorable)[5] Skullage i…
Jonglei State in 2010 Elections were held in Jonglei State on 10–15 April 2010 as part of the 2010 Sudanese general election, with voting for President of Sudan, National Assembly of Sudan, President of Southern Sudan, Southern Sudan Legislative Assembly, Governor of Jonglei State and the Jonglei State Legislative Assembly.[1][2] The elections were the first in Sudan for over two decades, held in the aftermath of the 2005 Comprehensive Peace Agreement between the Sudan People's…
هذه المقالة عن عبد الفتاح السيسي. لمعانٍ أخرى، طالع السيسي (توضيح). عبد الفتاح السيسي العلم الرئاسي رئيس جمهورية مصر العربية السادس تولى المنصب3 يونيو 2014[معلومة 1] رئيس الوزراء إبراهيم محلبشريف إسماعيلمصطفى مدبولي عدلي منصور (مؤقت)محمد مرسي (فعلي) النائب الأو…
Karakter utama dari seri yang muncul dalam Bagian I.Karakter utama dari seri yang muncul dalam Bagian II. Serial manga dan anime Naruto memiliki berbagai karakter yang diciptakan oleh Masashi Kishimoto. Serial ini berlangsung dalam dunia fiksi tempat setiap negara berebut kekuasaan melalui ninja yang dapat menggunakan kemampuannya dalam pertempuran. Alur cerita Naruto dibagi menjadi dua bagian, Bagian I dan Bagian II, dengan mengambil tempat terakhir dalam dua setengah tahun setelah akhir dari B…
2024 Philadelphia PhilliesLeagueNational LeagueDivisionEastBallparkCitizens Bank ParkCityPhiladelphiaOwnersJohn S. MiddletonPresident of baseball operationsDave DombrowskiManagersRob ThomsonTelevisionNBC Sports PhiladelphiaNBC Sports Philadelphia +NBC Philadelphia (Tom McCarthy, John Kruk, Ben Davis, Mike Schmidt, Jimmy Rollins, Rubén Amaro Jr.)RadioPhillies Radio Network WIP SportsRadio 94.1 FM (English)(Scott Franzke, Larry Andersen, Kevin Stocker)WTTM (Spanish)(Danny Martinez, Bill Kuli…
هذه المقالة يتيمة إذ تصل إليها مقالات أخرى قليلة جدًا. فضلًا، ساعد بإضافة وصلة إليها في مقالات متعلقة بها. (نوفمبر 2018) بعد الحفل الراقص (بالإنجليزية: After the Ball) الصنف كوميديا رومانسية تاريخ الصدور 1932 البلد المملكة المتحدة الولايات المتحدة اللغة الأصلية الإنجليز…
This article does not cite any sources. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: Piri Reis University – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (November 2010) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) Private university in Istanbul, Turkey Piri Reis UniversityPiri Reis ÜniversitesiTypePrivateEstablished8 February 2008PresidentProf. Dr. Nafiz Ar…
Niccolò dell'Arca (c. 1435 - Bolonia, 1494), conocido también como Niccolò d'Antonio d'Apulia o Niccolò da Bari, fue un escultor italiano activo en Bolonia, una de las figuras de la escultura de la Italia septentrional del siglo XV. Figuras del Llanto sobre Cristo muerto, una de las obras más importantes de Niccolò dell'Arca. Notas biográficas En los documentos más antiguos se le encuentra citado como de Apulia, lo que hace pensar en una procedencia meridional (el término Apulia en…