Share to: share facebook share twitter share wa share telegram print page

Therapeutic touch

Therapeutic touch
Alternative therapy
MeSHD019124
Part of a series on the
Paranormal
Main articles
Skepticism
Parapsychology
Related
Part of a series on
Alternative medicine
General information
Fringe medicine and science
Controversies
Classifications
Traditional medicine
Alternative diagnoses

Therapeutic touch (TT), or non-contact therapeutic touch (NCTT),[1] is a pseudoscientific[2] energy therapy which practitioners claim promotes healing and reduces pain and anxiety. "Therapeutic Touch" is a registered trademark in Canada for the "[s]tructured and standardized healing practice performed by practitioners trained to be sensitive to the receiver's energy field that surrounds the body;...no touching is required."[3]

Practitioners of therapeutic touch state that by placing their hands on, or near, a patient, they are able to detect and manipulate what they say is the patient's energy field.[4] One highly cited study, designed by the then-nine-year-old Emily Rosa and published in the Journal of the American Medical Association in 1998, found that practitioners of therapeutic touch could not detect the presence or absence of a hand placed a few inches above theirs when their vision was obstructed.[5][6][7][8] Simon Singh and Edzard Ernst concluded in their 2008 book Trick or Treatment that "the energy field was probably nothing more than a figment in the imaginations of the healers".[9] The American Cancer Society noted, "Available scientific evidence does not support any claims that TT can cure cancer or other diseases."[10] A 2004 Cochrane review found no good evidence that it helped with wound healing, but the authors withdrew it in 2016 "due to serious concerns over the validity of included studies".[11]

Origin and foundations

Dora Kunz, a theosophy promoter and one-time president (1975–1987) of the Theosophical Society in America, and Dolores Krieger, now Professor Emerita of Nursing Science, New York University,[12] developed therapeutic touch in the 1970s.[4][13][14][15] According to Krieger, therapeutic touch has roots in ancient healing practices,[16] such as the laying on of hands, although it has no connection with religion or with faith healing. Krieger states that, "in the final analysis, it is the healee (client) who heals himself. The healer or therapist, in this view, acts as a human energy support system until the healee's own immunological system is robust enough to take over".[17]

Justification for TT has been sought in two fields: Martha E. Rogers' contemporal "Science of Unitary Human Beings", and quantum mechanics, in particular Fritjof Capra's mystical interpretation of the latter. A 2002 review found that neither justification was tenable: Rogers' theories were found to be inconsistent with the tenets of TT, while the overlap in terminology between the two could be ascribed to a lack of precision in Rogers' works, making them multi-interpretable. The quantum physics justification holds that the possibility to heal at a distance is possible due to a "global interconnectivity" of the universe, which is connected by TT adherents to an interpretation of Bell's theorem and the possibility of quantum nonlocality; this interpretation is not supported by experimental evidence. The 2002 study concluded that "the theory TT possesses is deprived of explanatory power" and "evidence that supports the current picture of physical energy should be regarded as evidence against the theory of TT".[18]

The supposed healing in TT takes place via a discredited physical process called "electron transfer resonance", which physicist Alan Sokal describes as "nonsense".[2]

Scientific investigations

Over the decades, many clinical studies have been performed to investigate TT's efficacy, as well as various meta-analyses and at least one systematic review, yielding varying results and conclusions. O'Mathúna et al., in discussing these studies, note several problems, such as failure to exclude methodologically flawed studies and a susceptibility to the publication bias of complementary medicine journals, which carry a "preponderance of studies with positive results"; they argue that

in light of background scientific knowledge, the antecedent plausibility of TT is sufficiently low that any methodological flaw in a study will always provide a more plausible explanation for any positive findings.

— O'Mathúna et al.[18]

Emily Rosa, at nine years of age, conceived and executed a study on therapeutic touch. With the help of Stephen Barrett from Quackwatch and the assistance of her mother, Linda Rosa and her step-father Larry Sarner, Emily became the youngest researcher to have a paper accepted by the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA), which debunked the claim of therapeutic touch practitioners can reliably sense a "Human Energy Field." Twenty-one practitioners of therapeutic touch participated in her study. The practitioners sat on one side of a cardboard screen, while Emily sat on the other. The practitioners then placed their hands through holes in the screen. Emily flipped a coin to determine which of the practitioner's hands she would place hers over (approximately 4-5 inches above the subject's hand). The practitioners then were to say where her hand was by sensing her biofield. Although all of the participants had asserted that they would be able to do this, the actual results did not support therapeutic touch's fundamental claim. The practitioners had succeeded in locating Emily's hand 44% of the time, a rate within the range of chance.[6][7][13][19] JAMA editor George D. Lundberg, M.D, recommended that third-party payers and the public should question paying for this procedure "until or unless additional honest experimentation demonstrates an actual effect."[13]

There is no good medical evidence for the effectiveness of therapeutic touch. A Cochrane systematic review, first published in 2004, found "[t]here is no robust evidence that TT promotes healing of acute wounds",[20] but in 2016 the authors retracted it after the validity of the reviewed studies were questioned.[11] The American Cancer Society noted, "Available scientific evidence does not support any claims that TT can cure cancer or other diseases."[10]

Skeptical view of therapeutic touch

When examining the existing literature on therapeutic touch, it has been observed that these studies tend to only cite research that favours the desired findings.[21] There have been studies focused on therapeutic touch that have failed to include any research that has contradictory findings. However, it is very important for studies such as these to report all results found from other studies even if they may contradict the present study's hypothesis.

It is also important to use the appropriate controls in such studies.[21] There have been studies such as that by Grad, Cadoret, and Paul that have appeared at first glance to show the effectiveness of therapeutic touch, yet once replicated using the appropriate controls, they were shown to have nonsignificant results, therefore rendering the original results inconclusive.[22]

Researcher bias has been noted in studies examining therapeutic touch, such as that by Turner, in which he included such statements as, "If we can successfully complete this study, this will be the first real scientific evidence there is for therapeutic touch".[23] It is important for researchers not to bias the results in order to achieve their desired outcome, as bias can lead to a misrepresentation of the true effectiveness of therapy such as that of therapeutic touch.

Replication is another important factor.[23] A study on therapeutic touch by Wirth appeared to have successful results in which more than half of the subjects being treated by this therapy had healed by day 16, with no healing shown in the control group. However, closer examination of this study reveals that there were several trials to test therapy, that only two of the five trials were successful, and that the control group actually healed as well or better than the treatment group in the other three trials.[24] This makes the results of such a study inconclusive in showing any effectiveness of therapeutic touch.

Therapeutic touch and nursing education

Sokal, in 2006, reported generally accepted estimates of over 80 colleges and universities spread over 70 countries where therapeutic touch is taught as well as some 80 hospitals in North America where it is practiced. He added that "these figures should be taken with a grain of salt, inasmuch as both advocates and detractors [...] have an interest in exaggerating its incidence".[2]

Owen Hammer and James Underdown from the Independent Investigations Group examined nursing standards in California, where the California Board of Registered Nursing (CBRN) can award registered nurses taking classes in therapeutic touch with continuing education units (CEUs) required for licensure renewal. In 2006, Hammer and Underdown presented the board with the scientific evidence refuting the validity of therapeutic touch as a legitimate treatment, but the board did not change its policy.[25]

See also

References

  1. ^ Astin JA, Harkness E, Ernst E (June 2000). "The efficacy of "distant healing": a systematic review of randomized trials". Annals of Internal Medicine. 132 (11): 903–910. doi:10.7326/0003-4819-132-11-200006060-00009. PMID 10836918. S2CID 53089000.
  2. ^ a b c Sokal A (2006). "Pseudoscience and postmodernism: Antagonists or fellow-travelers?" (PDF). In Fagan GG (ed.). Archaeological Fantasies: How Pseudoarchaeology Misrepresents the Past and Misleads the Public. Routledge. pp. 286–361. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2013-09-27. Retrieved 2015-07-02.
  3. ^ Canadian Trade-marks database, Registration No. TMA580182.
  4. ^ a b Bruno LC (1999). "Therapeutic touch". Encyclopedia of Medicine. Gale Research. Retrieved 2007-07-07.
  5. ^ Larry Sarner (December 2007). "Therapeutic Touch Study Data". QuackWatch.
  6. ^ a b Glazer S (2000). "Postmodern Nursing". The Public Interest. Archived from the original on 2007-02-25. Retrieved 2007-07-07.
  7. ^ a b Rosa L, Rosa E, Sarner L, Barrett S (April 1998). "A close look at therapeutic touch". JAMA. 279 (13): 1005–1010. CiteSeerX 10.1.1.592.8130. doi:10.1001/jama.279.13.1005. PMID 9533499.
  8. ^ Stenger V (1999). "The Physics of 'Alternative Medicine' Bioenergetic Fields" (PDF). The Scientific Review of Alternative Medicine. Retrieved 17 June 2013.
  9. ^ Trick or Treatment. Corgi. 2008. pp. 267–268.
  10. ^ a b Ades TB, ed. (2009). "Therapeutic Touch". American Cancer Society Complete Guide to Complementary and Alternative Cancer Therapies (2nd ed.). American Cancer Society. pp. 248–251. ISBN 978-0-944235-71-3.
  11. ^ a b O'Mathúna DP (September 2016). "WITHDRAWN: Therapeutic touch for healing acute wounds". The Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. 2016 (9): CD002766. doi:10.1002/14651858.cd002766.pub6. PMC 6457586. PMID 27581995. 23/08/16 This review has been withdrawn due to serious concerns over the validity of included studies.
    The editorial group responsible for this previously published document have withdrawn it from publication.
  12. ^ Krieger D (1999). "Should nurses practice therapeutic touch? Should nursing schools teach therapeutic touch?". Journal of Professional Nursing. 15 (3): 200–201. doi:10.1016/S8755-7223(99)80043-X. PMID 10377630.
  13. ^ a b c Barrett, Stephen (26 May 1998). "Therapeutic Touch". quackwatch.com. Archived from the original on 2017-08-24.
  14. ^ Gholap A (21 May 2009). "Theos-Talk Archives (April 2005 Message tt00332)". theosophy.com. Archived from the original on 2016-08-18.
  15. ^ Denison, Barbara L (9 January 2008). "Consumer access to complementary therapies such as Therapeutic Touch (TT)". findarticles.com. Kansas Nurse. Archived from the original on 9 January 2008.
  16. ^ Krieger D (May 1975). "Therapeutic touch: the imprimatur of nursing". The American Journal of Nursing. 75 (5): 784–787. doi:10.2307/3423456. JSTOR 3423456. PMID 1039264.
  17. ^ Krieger, Dolores (1993). Accepting your power to heal: the personal practice of therapeutic touch. Internet Archive. Santa Fe, NM: Bear & Co. p. 7. ISBN 978-1-879181-04-5.
  18. ^ a b O'Mathúna DP, Pryjmachuk S, Spencer W, Stanwick M, Matthiesen S (2002). "A critical evaluation of the theory and practice of therapeutic touch". Nursing Philosophy. 3 (2): 163–176. doi:10.1046/j.1466-769x.2002.00089.x.
  19. ^ "Therapeutic touch, on season 8 , episode 2". Scientific American Frontiers. Chedd-Angier Production Company. 1997–1998. PBS. Archived from the original on 2006-01-01.
  20. ^ O'Mathúna DP (August 2016). O'Mathúna DP (ed.). "Therapeutic touch for healing acute wounds". The Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews (8): CD002766. doi:10.1002/14651858.CD002766.pub5. PMID 27552401. (Retracted, see doi:10.1002/14651858.CD002766.pub6, PMID 27581995)
  21. ^ a b O'Mathuna, Donal P. (September 2000). "Evidence-based practice and reviews of therapeutic touch". Journal of Nursing Scholarship. 32 (3): 279–85. doi:10.1111/j.1547-5069.2000.00279.x. PMID 12462823. ProQuest 236433132.
  22. ^ Grad B, Cadoret RJ, Paul GI (1961). "An unorthodox method of treatment on wound healing in mice". International Journal of Parapsychology. 3: 5–24.
  23. ^ a b Courcey, Kevin (November 2001). "Investigating therapeutic touch". Nurse Practitioner. 26 (11): 12–3. doi:10.1097/00006205-200111000-00002. PMID 11759612. ProQuest 222268740.
  24. ^ Wirth DP (1990). "The effect of non-contact therapeutic touch on the healing rate of full thickness dermal wounds". Subtle Energies. 1: 1–20.
  25. ^ Hammer O, Underdown J (November–December 2009). "State-Sponsored Quackery: Feng Shui and Snake Oil for California Nurses". Skeptical Inquirer. 33 (6). Committee for Skeptical Inquiry: 53–56.
Wikimedia Commons has media related to Therapeutic touch.

Read other articles:

Local currency

Currency that can be spent in a particular geographical locality at participating organisations. Part of a series onNumismaticsthe study of currency Glossary Currency Coins Banknotes Forgery List ISO Circulating currencies Africa The Americas Europe Asia Oceania Local currencies Company scrip LETS Time dollars Fictional currencies Proposed currencies History of money Historical currencies Aksumite Achaemenid Byzantine Chinese Filipino Greek Indian Italy Japan Roman Thai Tibetan Medieval curre...

 

Tiada Jalan Lain

Tiada Jalan LainSutradara Hasmanan Produser Robby Tjahjadi Robby Sumampow Suen FL Ditulis olehPemeranTeng Kuang YungDebby Cynthia DewiBambang HermantoTang WeiKomalasariA. Hamid AriefS. BonoAbidin SupuJocom ComoHanny RayPenata musikIdris SardiSinematograferMochtarChen Long ShuTanggal rilis1972Durasi... menitNegara Indonesia Bahasa Indonesia Tiada Jalan Lain adalah film Indonesia tahun 1972 dengan disutradarai oleh Hasmanan yang dibintangi oleh Teng Kuang Yung dan Debby Cynthia Dewi. Film...

 

Hannibal Sehested (governor)

Danish diplomat (1609–1666) For the later prime minister, see Hannibal Sehested (council president). Hannibal Sehested Hannibal Sehested (1609 – 23 September 1666) was a Dano-Norwegian statesman and son-in-law of King Christian IV. He served as Governor-general of Norway from 1642 to 1651. He fought in the Torstenson War against Sweden and implemented many reforms in Norway.[1][2] After a fall from grace leading to his resignation as Governor-general in 1651, he regained t...

Fiting

Artikel ini tidak memiliki referensi atau sumber tepercaya sehingga isinya tidak bisa dipastikan. Tolong bantu perbaiki artikel ini dengan menambahkan referensi yang layak. Tulisan tanpa sumber dapat dipertanyakan dan dihapus sewaktu-waktu.Cari sumber: Fiting – berita · surat kabar · buku · cendekiawan · JSTOR Fiting lampu atau tampuk lampu (bahasa Inggris: lightbulb fitting, lamp holder) adalah sebuah tempat untuk menaruh sebuah lampu bohlam, yang ber...

 

Dewan Perwakilan Rakyat Daerah Kabupaten Lebak

Dewan Perwakilan Rakyat Daerah Kabupaten LebakDewan Perwakilan RakyatKabupaten Lebak2019-2024JenisJenisUnikameral SejarahSesi baru dimulai26 Agustus 2019PimpinanKetuaMuhammad Agil Zulfikar, S.IP. (Gerindra) sejak 26 April 2021 Wakil Ketua IUcuy Masyhuri, S.Pd.I. (Demokrat) sejak 30 September 2019 Wakil Ketua IIJunaedi Ibnu Jarta, S.Hut. (PDI-P) sejak 30 September 2019 Wakil Ketua IIIH. Nana Sumarna, S.H. (Golkar) sejak 30 September 2019 KomposisiAnggota50Partai & kursi...

 

Cross of Military Merit (Ukraine)

For the Spain order of the similar name, see Cross of Military Merit. AwardCross of Military MeritTypeCrossAwarded forOutstanding personal bravery and courage or an outstanding heroic act while performing a combat mission in conditions of danger to life and direct contact with the enemy; outstanding success in the management of troops (forces) during military (combat) operationsPresented by UkraineEligibilityCitizens of Ukraine, foreigners and stateless personsEstablished5 May 2022 Prece...

Niggas Is Men

2013 mixtape by Quelle ChrisNiggas Is MenMixtape by Quelle ChrisReleasedMarch 19, 2013 (2013-03-19)GenreHip hopLength45:48LabelMello Music GroupProducer Michael Tolle (exec.) Quelle Chris (also exec.) Messiah Musik Sifu Quelle Chris chronology 2Dirt4TV(2012) Niggas Is Men(2013) Ghost at the Finish Line(2015) Too Dirt For TV2 – Niggas Is Men is a 2013 mixtape album by American rapper and producer Quelle Chris. It featured audio production handled by Messiah Musik, Sifu...

 

Hazara Democratic Party

Political party in Pakistan Hazara Democratic Party ہزارہ ڈیموکریٹک پارٹیAbbreviationHDPChairmanAbdul Khaliq HazaraFounderHussain Ali YousafiFounded2003HeadquartersQuettaStudent wingHazara Student FederationIdeologySocial democracyDemocratic socialismPolitical positionCentre-leftBalochistan AssemblyAssembly dissolvedElection symbolMoon (مافـتی)Party flagWebsitehttp://www.hdp.org.pkPolitics of PakistanPolitical partiesElections Politics of Pakistan Federal gov...

 

Ingeniería de confiabilidad

Árbol de fallas La ingeniería de confiabilidad (en inglés, reliability engineering) es una subdisciplina de la ingeniería de sistemas que enfatiza la capacidad de los equipos físicos para funcionar sin fallas. La confiabilidad describe la capacidad de un sistema o componente para funcionar en las condiciones establecidas durante un período de tiempo específico.[1]​[2]​[3]​ La confiabilidad está estrechamente relacionada con la disponibilidad, que generalmente se desc...

Schunemunk Mountain

Mountain in United States of America This article uses bare URLs, which are uninformative and vulnerable to link rot. Please consider converting them to full citations to ensure the article remains verifiable and maintains a consistent citation style. Several templates and tools are available to assist in formatting, such as reFill (documentation) and Citation bot (documentation). (August 2022) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) Schunemunk MountainSchunemunk Mountain from ac...

 

Sampo (1960 icebreaker)

Ship Sampo at dock History Finland NameSampo OperatorKemi Tourism Ltd. BuilderOy Wärtsilä Ab Hietalahti shipyard Launched9 February 1960 Completed1961 HomeportKemi, Finland Identification IMO number: 5308938 MMSI number: 230990040 Callsign: OIWK Nickname(s)Sampo Arctic Icebreaker StatusActive General characteristics Typeicebreaker Displacement3,542 tonnes Length75.68 m (248.3 ft) Beam17.40 m (57.1 ft) Height14 m (46 ft) Draught7 m (23 ft) Decks7 ...

 

Jaakko Hämeen-Anttila

Finnish academic Jaakko Hämeen-AnttilaJaakko Hämeen-Anttila in 2017.Born (1963-02-26) 26 February 1963 (age 60)OuluNationalityFinnishScientific careerFieldsArabic language and IslamInstitutionsUniversity of HelsinkiUniversity of EdinburghDoctoral advisorKaj Öhrnberg Jaakko Hämeen-Anttila (born 26 February 1963)[1] is a Finnish academic researcher, serving as a professor of the Arabic language and Islamic studies at the University of Edinburgh.[2] Before that he was a ...

Sajid Khan

Indian actor and singer (born 1951) This article is about the actor. For the director, see Sajid Khan (director). For the cricketer, see Sajid Khan (cricketer). For the musical director Sajid Khan part of a duo, see Sajid–Wajid. Sajid KhanSajid Khan in Maya TV series (1967)Born (1951-12-28) 28 December 1951 (age 71)Bombay, Bombay State, IndiaOther namesSajid MehboobYears active1957–2001 Sajid Khan (born 28 December 1951) is an Indian actor and singer. Born into poverty in t...

 

The Portrait (Magritte)

Painting by René Magritte The PortraitArtistRené MagritteYear1935MediumOil on canvasDimensions73.3 cm × 50.2 cm (28⅞ in × 19⅞ in)LocationMuseum of Modern Art, New York City The Portrait (1935) is a painting by the Belgian surrealist René Magritte. It depicts an almost photo-realistic table setting with a slice of ham in the center, with an eye staring back at the viewer from the center of the ham. This painting was once part of the private co...

 

Villanova Monteleone

Villanova Monteleone Biddanòa MonteleòneKomuneComune di Villanova MonteleoneLokasi Villanova Monteleone di Provinsi SassariNegara ItaliaWilayah SardiniaProvinsiSassari (SS)Pemerintahan • Wali kotaQuirico MeloniLuas[1] • Total202,68 km2 (78,26 sq mi)Ketinggian[2]567 m (1,860 ft)Populasi (2016)[3] • Total2,304 • Kepadatan11/km2 (29/sq mi)Zona waktuUTC+1 (CET) • Musim pan...

Nintendo Video

This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: Nintendo Video – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (July 2011) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) Nintendo Video[a] is a video on demand service for the Nintendo 3DS which streams hand-picked[1] 3D and 2D video conten...

 

Antigua

Halaman ini berisi artikel tentang pulau. Untuk informasi lebih rinci tentang Antigua sebagai entitas politik, lihat Antigua dan Barbuda. Untuk tempat lain bernama Antigua, lihat Antigua (disambiguasi). Untuk kota di Guatemalan, lihat Antigua Guatemala. AntiguaNama lokal: WaladliPeta Antigua dan parokinyaGeografiLokasiLaut KaribiaKoordinat17°5′N 61°48′W / 17.083°N 61.800°W / 17.083; -61.800Koordinat: 17°5′N 61°48′W / 17.083°N 61.800°W&#x...

 

Cinenen jawa

Cinenen jawa Status konservasi Risiko Rendah (IUCN 3.1) Klasifikasi ilmiah Kerajaan: Animalia Filum: Chordata Kelas: Aves Ordo: Passeriformes Famili: Cisticolidae Genus: Orthotomus Spesies: O. sepium Nama binomial Orthotomus sepiumHorsfield, 1821 Cinenen jawa (bahasa Latin: Orthotomus sepium) adalah spesies burung dari keluarga Cisticolidae, dari genus Orthotomus. Burung ini merupakan endemik di Indonesia, dan merupakan jenis burung pemakan ulat, laba-laba, serangga keci dan mem...

Sarnitsa, Pazardzhik Province

This article is about the town of Sarnitsa. For the village of the same name in Haskovo Province, see Sarnitsa, Haskovo Province. You can help expand this article with text translated from the corresponding article in Bulgarian. (October 2013) Click [show] for important translation instructions. View a machine-translated version of the Bulgarian article. Machine translation, like DeepL or Google Translate, is a useful starting point for translations, but translators must revise errors as...

 

Bitch Slap

2009 action and exploitation film directed by Rick Jacobson For other uses, see Bitch Slap (disambiguation). This article's lead section may be too short to adequately summarize the key points. Please consider expanding the lead to provide an accessible overview of all important aspects of the article. (August 2010) Bitch SlapTheatrical release posterDirected byRick JacobsonWritten byRick JacobsonEric GruendemannProduced byEric GruendemannRick JacobsonStarringJulia VothErin CummingsAmerica Ol...

 
Kembali kehalaman sebelumnya