Share to: share facebook share twitter share wa share telegram print page

Of Education

Of Education is a treatise by John Milton published in 1644, first appearing anonymously as a single eight-page quarto sheet (Ainsworth 6). Presented as a letter, written in response to a request from the Puritan educational reformer Samuel Hartlib, it represents Milton's most comprehensive statement on educational reform (Viswanathan 352), and gives voice to his views "concerning the best and noblest way of education" (Milton 63). As outlined in the tractate, education carried for Milton a dual objective: one public, to “fit a man to perform justly, skillfully, and magnanimously all the offices, both private and public, of peace and war” (55); and the other private, to “repair the ruins of our first parents by regaining to know God aright, and out of that knowledge to love Him, to be like Him, as we may the nearest by possessing our soul of true virtue” (52).

Influences

The influences at work in the tractate are an interesting blend of Renaissance humanism with its emphasis on the via activa, tempered by the more contemplative medieval concern with personal redemption. It is clear, however, that the overwhelming thrust of Milton's educational programme as outlined in the tractate is centred in the public objective. This is likely a reaction to the scholasticism that dominated the medieval university from the twelfth century, which still held sway in Milton's time (Ainsworth 25).

Important individual influences on Milton's tractate include Spanish educator Juan Luis Vives (1492–1540) and Moravian educator John Comenius (1592–1670). Both Vives and Comenius rejected the dialectical approach in education in favour of empirical observation and “the study of things rather than words, nature rather than books” (Lewalski 204). In an interesting fusion of empiricism and morality, both educators promoted the idea that the study of nature was instrumental to the formation of moral character (Viswanathan 352).

Milton's educational views

Medieval education

The objective of medieval education was an overtly religious one, primarily concerned with uncovering transcendental truths that would lead a person back to God through a life of moral and religious choice (Kreeft 15). The vehicle by which these truths were uncovered was dialectic:

To the medieval mind, debate was a fine art, a serious science, and a fascinating entertainment, much more than it is to the modern mind, because the medievals believed, like Socrates, that dialectic could uncover truth. Thus a ‘scholastic disputation’ was not a personal contest in cleverness, nor was it ‘sharing opinions’; it was a shared journey of discovery (Kreeft 14–15).

The learners in the Middle Ages were the clerics who comprised the literate segment of medieval society and who were responsible for the production, transmission and exposition of scholarly texts, both sacred and classical (Hanning 594). Their 'shared journey of discovery' had become, by Milton's time, an academic exercise so divorced from the practical realities of life as to render medieval education repulsive to Renaissance humanists in general, and to Milton in particular, for whom "the scholastic grossness of barbarous ages" did little more than immerse students in "unquiet deeps of controversy", leaving them with "ragged notions and babblements" and "such things chiefly as were better unlearned" (Milton 54; hereafter cited by page number alone). Milton dismissed the medieval curriculum which produced such scholars as the "scragged and thorny lectures of monkish and miserable sophistry" (Lewalski 208), and sought to liberate it from the scholastic yoke from which he believed it desperately needed rescuing.

The Medieval curriculum

Numerical finger codes, from the De Numeris by Raban Maur, thirteenth century.

The medieval curriculum was characterised throughout by a preoccupation with the speculative. It began with the trivium, which included the study of grammar, rhetoric and dialectic. Grammar instruction dominated the early years of a student's education, where the focus, as Witt explains, was exclusively linguistic: “…in a school program where the student aimed at perfecting a prose style largely divorced from classical precedents, the emphasis in teaching grammar fell on providing instruction more in the mechanics of the language than in ancient literature” (26). The trivium laid the groundwork for the quadrivium, which turned its attention to the theoretical in the world of number, including the study of arithmetic, geometry, music, and astronomy. These two foundational programmes prepared the medieval university student for the study of philosophy and theology with its heavy emphasis on dialectical reasoning.

Milton's proposed curriculum

Milton is clear in the tract about the "many mistakes" that encumbered the medieval curriculum, which he censures as making "learning generally so unpleasing and unsuccessful" (53) in his time. His first target is the instruction of grammar. Milton is critical both of the amount of time spent on it as well as its mechanical emphasis: “we do amiss to spend seven or eight years merely in scraping together so much miserable Latin and Greek as might be learned otherwise easily and delightfully in one year” (53). Progress, in his view, is delayed by unnecessarily “forcing the empty wits of children to compose theme, verses, and orations” (53); instead, he proposes that after some foundational grammatical instruction, students should “be won early to the love of virtue” by having “some easy and delightful book of education” from among the ancient classics read to them (56). The objective is not simply to teach grammar, but to “inflame [students] with the study of learning” (56). This, for Milton, was best accomplished through the reading of great literature.

After grammar, Milton takes up the cause of curricular sequence. He derides the medieval practice of “present[ing] their young unmatriculated novices, at first coming, with the most intellective abstractions of logic and metaphysics” after having only recently left "those grammatic flats and shallows where they stuck unreasonably to learn a few words with lamentable construction" (54). Instead, he proposes “beginning with arts most easy”; that is to say, those "most obvious to the sense" (54). His method, as Riggs notes, is an inductive one, starting with the study of "sensible things" (52), and progressing to "things invisible" only after mastering the former (Riggs 450). This move effectively inverts the deductive method common in medieval education. The "organic arts" of rhetoric and logic therefore find a place at the end of Milton's curriculum, rather than at the beginning (59). Noteworthy too is Milton's inclusion of poetry amongst the other organic arts: “poetry would be made subsequent, or indeed, rather precedent, as being less subtle and fine, but more simple, sensuous, and passionate” (60).

Milton's proposed curriculum, encompassing as it does grammar, arithmetic, geometry, religion, agriculture, geography, astronomy, physics, trigonometry, ethics, economics, languages, politics, the law, theology, church history as well as the “organic arts” of poetry, rhetoric and logic, is encyclopaedic in scope. His main thrust in the educational enterprise remains, however, on that practical erudition which would serve both the individual in a moral sense and the state in a public sense, equipping people “to be brave men and worthy patriots, dear to God and famous to all ages” (56). This stands in contrast to the contemplative and speculative concerns of medieval education.

Influences from Renaissance humanism

As Ainsworth points out, “Milton, like other genuine humanists, cared little for virtue apart from practice, or for talent without principle” (15). Milton's desire to marry scholarly pursuits to commitments of a professional and public nature is, as Ainsworth implies, an over-riding characteristic of Renaissance humanism (Witt 34). Briefly stated, the humanist educational agenda of the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries included “a clearer consciousness, among teachers and students, of education as a discipline for active life”, combined with "an insistence on the more extensive reading of ancient writers both classical and Christian as a means of securing this discipline" and "an attitude of severe and hostile criticism toward medieval education and culture" (Ainsworth 8).

The changing demands of society

The shift in educational concerns evident in the Renaissance was informed by the changing structure of society at this time. The ecclesiastical world of the Middle Ages, which was well served by its clerics, slowly gave way, in the sixteenth century, to a burgeoning bureaucratic world, served by the clerks who oiled the machinery of government, “keeping records, accounts, and correspondence” (Viswanathan 349). A linguistic and salvational emphasis in education was no longer tenable as the Puritans came to demand a general and practical education for their children. Education thus became concerned with "instilling into students a consciousness of themselves as national subjects" where moral concerns were public as well as private (Viswanathan 350). Milton's tractate fits well into this trajectory in its accommodation of education "to the needs of an age" (Ainsworth 42).

References

  • Ainsworth, Morley Oliver, ed. Milton on Education: The Tractate of Education with Supplementary Extracts from Other Writings of Milton. New Haven: Yale UP, 1928.
  • Hanning, Robert W. “From Eva and Ave to Eglentyne and Alisoun: Chaucer’s Insight in the Roles Women Play.” Signs 2.3 (Spring, 1977): 580–599.
  • Kreeft, Peter. Summa of the Summa. San Francisco: Ignatius P, 1990.
  • Lewalski, Barbara K. "Milton and the Hartlib Circle: Educational Projects and Epic Paideia." Literary Milton: Text, Pretext, Context. Eds. Diana Benet and Michael Lieb. Pittsburgh: Duquesne UP, 1994. 202–19.
  • Luxon, Thomas H., ed. "Of Education." The Milton Reading Room. March 2002. 4 Nov 2005 [1]
  • Milton, John. "Of Education." Milton on Education: The Tractate of Education with Supplementary Extracts from Other Writings of Milton. Ed. Morley Oliver Ainsworth. New Haven: Yale UP, 1928. 51–64.
  • Riggs, William G. "Poetry and Method in Milton's Of Education." Studies in Philology 89 (1992): 445–69.
  • Tinsley, Barbara Sher. Johann Sturm's method for humanistic pedagogy. Sixteenth century journal 20 (1989): 23–39.
  • Viswanathan, Gauri. "Milton, Imperialism, and Education." Modern Language Quarterly: A Journal of Literary History 59 (1998): 345–61.
  • Witt, Ronald G. “Medieval ‘Ars dictaminis’ and the beginnings of humanism: a new construction of the problem.” Renaissance Quarterly 35.1 (Spring, 1982): 1–35.

Read other articles:

Japanese anime television series El Cazador de la BrujaLimited edition cover of the first DVD volumeエル・カザド(Eru Kazado)GenreAdventure,[1] girls with guns,[2] modern Western,[3] Yuri[4] Anime television seriesDirected byKōichi MashimoProduced byShigeru KitayamaMamiko AokiWritten byKenichi KanemakiMusic byYuki KajiuraStudioBee TrainLicensed byNA: Funimation Entertainment[5]Original networkTV TokyoEnglish networkUS: Funima…

Cina ai Giochi della XXVIII OlimpiadeAtene 2004 Codice CIO CHN Comitato nazionale Comitato Olimpico Cinese Atleti partecipanti 384 in 31 discipline Di cui uomini/donne 136 - 248 Portabandiera Yao Ming Medagliere Posizione 2ª 32 17 14 63 Cronologia olimpica (sommario) Giochi olimpici estivi 1952 · 1956 · 1960 · 1964 · 1968 · 1972 · 1976 · 1980 · 1984 · 1988 · 1992 · 1996 · 2000 · 2004 · 2008 

Société des Moteurs et Voitures Automobiles Filtz Rechtsform Société Gründung 1899 Auflösung nach 1910 Sitz Neuilly-sur-Seine, Frankreich Branche Motorenbau, Automobilindustrie Die Société des Moteurs et Voitures Automobiles Filtz war ein französischer Hersteller von Automobilen.[1][2][3] Inhaltsverzeichnis 1 Unternehmensgeschichte 2 Fahrzeuge 3 Motoren 4 Motorenlieferungen 5 Literatur 6 Einzelnachweise Unternehmensgeschichte Filtz Traktor Das Unternehmen aus Neu…

List of statistical leaders of the Tulane Green Wave football program The Tulane Green Wave football statistical leaders are individual statistical leaders of the Tulane Green Wave football program in various categories,[1] including passing, rushing, receiving, total offense, defensive stats, and kicking. Within those areas, the lists identify single-game, single-season, and career leaders. The Green Wave represent Tulane University in the NCAA Division I FBS American Athletic Conferenc…

Бутанон Інші назви Метилетилкетон Ідентифікатори Номер CAS 78-93-3PubChem 6569Номер EINECS 201-159-0KEGG C02845ChEBI 28398RTECS EL6475000SMILES CCC(=O)CInChI 1/C4H8O/c1-3-4(2)5/h3H2,1-2H3Номер Бельштейна 741880Номер Гмеліна 25656 Властивості Молекулярна формула C4H8O Молярна маса 72,10572 г/моль-1 Зовнішній вигляд Безбарвна рідина Густи

2013 Leeds Rhinos seasonSuper League XVIII Rank3rdPlay-off resultSemi-finalChallenge Cup5th round2013 recordWins: 21; draws: 1; losses: 9Points scoredFor: 773; against: 577Team informationChairmanPaul CaddickHead CoachBrian McDermottCaptainKevin SinfieldStadiumHeadingley StadiumTop scorersTriesKallum Watkins - 20GoalsKevin Sinfield - 106PointsKevin Sinfield - 230 < 2012 List of seasons 2014 > This article details the Leeds Rhinos rugby league football clu…

2020 United States presidential election polling ← 2016 November 3, 2020 (2020-11-03) 2024 → Leading presidential candidate by state or district, based on opinion polls.This map only represents polling data, it is not a prediction for the election. Joe Biden▼Donald Trump 183 33 36 162 44 20 60 Legend Lead    >15%       10–15%       5–10%       <5%    Leads are based on…

هذه المقالة يتيمة إذ تصل إليها مقالات أخرى قليلة جدًا. فضلًا، ساعد بإضافة وصلة إليها في مقالات متعلقة بها. (أكتوبر 2016) علي بن يحي شوك معلومات شخصية مكان الميلاد صامطة، منطقة جازان مكان الوفاة ظهران الجنوب مكان الدفن المقالي، منطقة جازان الجنسية  السعودية الحياة العملية ال

العلاقات الغامبية اللبنانية غامبيا لبنان   غامبيا   لبنان تعديل مصدري - تعديل   العلاقات الغامبية اللبنانية هي العلاقات الثنائية التي تجمع بين غامبيا ولبنان.[1][2][3][4][5] مقارنة بين البلدين هذه مقارنة عامة ومرجعية للدولتين: وجه المقارنة غامبيا …

Горбатий кит (Megaptera novaeangliae), представник ряду китопарнокопитних. Морські ссавці — група водних і напівводних ссавців, що постійно або тимчасово мешкають у морській воді, або залежать від неї для отримання їжі. Зміст 1 Обсяг групи 2 Класифікація існуючих видів 3 Особливост…

Organ system within humans and other animals Enteric redirects here. For other uses, see Enteric (disambiguation). DigestionDiagram of stomach, intestines and rectum in the average humanDetailsSystemDigestive systemIdentifiersLatintractus digestorius (mouth to anus),canalis alimentarius (esophagus to large intestine),canalis gastrointestinales stomach to large intestine)MeSHD041981Anatomical terminology[edit on Wikidata] Major parts of theGastrointestinal tract Upper gastrointestinal tract M…

Liga Champions UEFA 2018–19Wanda Metropolitano di Madrid merupakan tempat penyelenggaraan pertandingan finalInformasi turnamenJadwalpenyelenggaraanKualifikasi:26 Juni – 29 Agustus 2018Kompetisi utama:18 September 2018 – 1 Juni 2019Jumlahtim pesertaKompetisi utama: 32Total: 79 (dari 54 asosiasi)Hasil turnamenJuara Liverpool (gelar ke-6)Tempat kedua Tottenham HotspurStatistik turnamenJumlahpertandingan125Jumlah gol366 (2,93 per pertandingan)Jumlahpenonton6.163.044 (49.304 per …

Jia YifanInformasi pribadiKebangsaan TiongkokLahir29 Juni 1997 (umur 26)Tianjin, TiongkokTinggi170 m (557 ft 9 in)PeganganKiriGanda putri & campuranPeringkat tertinggi1 (WD 2 November 2017) 97 (XD 1 September 2016)Peringkat saat ini1 bersama Chen Qingchen (27 Desember 2022[1])Profil di BWF Jia Yifan (Hanzi: 贾一凡; Pinyin: Jiǎ Yīfán; Pengucapan Mandarin: [tɕjà.í fǎn]; lahir 29 Juni 1997) adalah pemain bulu tangkis pu…

العلاقات الإندونيسية الكرواتية إندونيسيا كرواتيا   إندونيسيا   كرواتيا تعديل مصدري - تعديل   العلاقات الإندونيسية الكرواتية هي العلاقات الثنائية التي تجمع بين إندونيسيا وكرواتيا.[1][2][3][4][5] مقارنة بين البلدين هذه مقارنة عامة ومرجعية للدولت…

Halaman ini berisi artikel tentang siklon tropis Atlantik tahun 2021. Untuk badai lain dengan nama yang sama, lihat Badai tropis Ida. Artikel ini bukan mengenai Siklon Idai atau Siklon Ita. Hurikan IdaHurikan mayor 4 (SSHWS/NWS)Hurikan Ida pada puncak intensitas menjelang pendaratan di Louisiana pada 29 AgustusTerbentuk pada26 Agustus 2021Mereda pada4 September 2021(Keluar wilayah tropis pada 1 September) Kecepatan anginmaksimal1 menit: 150 mil/jam (240 km/jam) Tekanan minimal929 mbar (hPa) Korb…

For the film by Michael Curtiz, see Nameless (1923 film). 2008 studio album by L'Âme ImmortelleNamenlosStudio album by L'Âme ImmortelleReleasedJanuary 25, 2008Recorded2007GenreEBM Gothic rock DarkwaveLabelTrisol Music GroupProducerL'Âme ImmortelleL'Âme Immortelle chronology Auf deinen Schwingen(2006) Namenlos(2008) Durch fremde Hand(2008) Namenlos (German for nameless) is the eighth studio album from Austrian band L'Âme Immortelle.[1] Track listing CD1: Namenlos[2] N…

American educator and businessman Amos Starr Cookec. 1859Born(1810-12-01)December 1, 1810Danbury, ConnecticutDiedMarch 20, 1871(1871-03-20) (aged 60)Honolulu, HawaiiOccupation(s)Educator, BusinessmanSpouseJuliette MontagueChildren7Parent(s)Joseph Platt Cooke Annis Starr Amos Starr Cooke (December 1, 1810 – March 20, 1871) was an American educator and businessman in the Kingdom of Hawaii. He was patriarch of a family that influenced Hawaii during the 20th century. Life Hawaii's Big F…

Roman mosaic motif This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: Xenia motif – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (December 2017) (Learn how and when to remove this template message)Xenia items in compartments, Sousse Museum The xenia motif in Roman mosaic is a still life motif consisting of a groupi…

2023 New Japan Pro-Wrestling professional wrestling event ResurgencePromotional poster featuring Mercedes MonéPromotionNew Japan Pro-WrestlingNJPW StrongDateMay 21, 2023CityLong Beach, CaliforniaVenueWalter PyramidEvent chronology ← PreviousBest of the Super Jr. 30 Next →Dominion 6.4 in Osaka-jo Hall Resurgence chronology ← Previous2021 Next →— The 2023 Resurgence was a professional wrestling pay-per-view (PPV) event produced by New Japan Pro-Wrestling (NJPW). …

Untuk sistem yang berkebalikan, lihat unggah. Tiga ikon unduhan Unduh adalah sistem yang bekerja dengan cara mengambil data dari jarak jauh, biasanya dari peladen;[1] misalnya dari peladen web, peladen Protokol Transfer Berkas (FTP), peladen surel, dan sistem serupa lainnya. Berbeda dengan unggahan yang bekerja dengan cara mengirim data ke peladen jarak jauh.[2] Definisi Data unduhan dikirim ke hilir ke pengguna akhir, ke hulu dari penyedia. ISP = penyedia jasa internet. Mengundu…

Kembali kehalaman sebelumnya